The use of aeration in constructed wetlands and the potential for earthworm and crop production
- Authors: Cesler, Lia
- Date: 2024-10-11
- Subjects: Constructed wetlands South Africa , Breweries South Africa , Water Purification , Land treatment of wastewater , Sewage Purification Aeration
- Language: English
- Type: Academic theses , Master's theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/464440 , vital:76511
- Description: Constructed wetlands (CWs) are used in a variety of industries to treat effluent for safe reuse or discharge. They can however take up large areas of land. Adding oxygen can increase treatment efficiency, as it is vital to many nutrient removal pathways, such as nitrification and aerobic respiration. Increasing efficiency can decrease the cost of treatment and reduce land area needed to operate a CW. The study aimed to find the best method of aerating wetlands treating brewery effluent, the potential production of worms and plants in the system and their effects on water treatment. The first experiment tested a hybrid constructed wetland, using small (1.0 m3) ebb and flow filtration additions to a horizontal subsurface flow constructed wetland against nanobubble aeration in a similar horizontal flow wetland cell. It was not possible to add replicates to the study, but findings prompted further investigation into the hybrid setup. Experiment two focussed on the ebb and flow filters within the hybrid system comparing the presence of plants and worms. The ebb and flow filters increased dissolved oxygen (DO) from an average inflow of 3.89 mg/L to an outflow of 5.70 mg/L and decreased the ammonia content of the effluent from 14.8 mg/L to 11.2 mg/L. Swiss chard (Beta vulgaris) was successfully grown in the system and was found not to affect DO. The addition of both Swiss chard and earthworms (Eisenia fetida) was found to decrease PO43- by 17.69 ± 1.36 %. Experiment 3 compared the previous ebb and flow filters to trickle filters with the addition of celery (Apium graveolens) to both systems to determine which filter treated the effluent more effectively. The ebb and flow filters performed better than the trickle filters, increasing the DO by 37.54 ± 0.06 % compared to 19.22 ± 0.06 %. Celery increased this change in both systems, to 44.16 ± 0.06 % in the ebb and flow filters and 30.96 ± 0.06 % in the trickle filters. The ebb and flow filters were also able to decrease the NH3-N concentration by 36.1 ± 0.2 %. This effluent could sustain plant growth; Swiss chard grew at a rate of 0.04 ± 0.02 g/g/d and celery at 0.2 ± 0.1 g/g/d. Ebb and flow filters are better at aerating brewery effluent and decreasing nutrient load than nanobubble pumps and trickle filters. The addition of ebb and flow filters to the CW treating brewery effluent has the potential to improve nutrient removal and provide an edible crop. , Thesis (MSc) -- Faculty of Science, Ichthyology and Fisheries Science, 2024
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2024-10-11
- Authors: Cesler, Lia
- Date: 2024-10-11
- Subjects: Constructed wetlands South Africa , Breweries South Africa , Water Purification , Land treatment of wastewater , Sewage Purification Aeration
- Language: English
- Type: Academic theses , Master's theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/464440 , vital:76511
- Description: Constructed wetlands (CWs) are used in a variety of industries to treat effluent for safe reuse or discharge. They can however take up large areas of land. Adding oxygen can increase treatment efficiency, as it is vital to many nutrient removal pathways, such as nitrification and aerobic respiration. Increasing efficiency can decrease the cost of treatment and reduce land area needed to operate a CW. The study aimed to find the best method of aerating wetlands treating brewery effluent, the potential production of worms and plants in the system and their effects on water treatment. The first experiment tested a hybrid constructed wetland, using small (1.0 m3) ebb and flow filtration additions to a horizontal subsurface flow constructed wetland against nanobubble aeration in a similar horizontal flow wetland cell. It was not possible to add replicates to the study, but findings prompted further investigation into the hybrid setup. Experiment two focussed on the ebb and flow filters within the hybrid system comparing the presence of plants and worms. The ebb and flow filters increased dissolved oxygen (DO) from an average inflow of 3.89 mg/L to an outflow of 5.70 mg/L and decreased the ammonia content of the effluent from 14.8 mg/L to 11.2 mg/L. Swiss chard (Beta vulgaris) was successfully grown in the system and was found not to affect DO. The addition of both Swiss chard and earthworms (Eisenia fetida) was found to decrease PO43- by 17.69 ± 1.36 %. Experiment 3 compared the previous ebb and flow filters to trickle filters with the addition of celery (Apium graveolens) to both systems to determine which filter treated the effluent more effectively. The ebb and flow filters performed better than the trickle filters, increasing the DO by 37.54 ± 0.06 % compared to 19.22 ± 0.06 %. Celery increased this change in both systems, to 44.16 ± 0.06 % in the ebb and flow filters and 30.96 ± 0.06 % in the trickle filters. The ebb and flow filters were also able to decrease the NH3-N concentration by 36.1 ± 0.2 %. This effluent could sustain plant growth; Swiss chard grew at a rate of 0.04 ± 0.02 g/g/d and celery at 0.2 ± 0.1 g/g/d. Ebb and flow filters are better at aerating brewery effluent and decreasing nutrient load than nanobubble pumps and trickle filters. The addition of ebb and flow filters to the CW treating brewery effluent has the potential to improve nutrient removal and provide an edible crop. , Thesis (MSc) -- Faculty of Science, Ichthyology and Fisheries Science, 2024
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2024-10-11
Mitigating salt accumulation in recycled brewery effluent through the integration of water treatment, agriculture and aquaculture
- Authors: Mabasa, Nyiko Charity
- Date: 2021-10-29
- Subjects: Brewery waste South Africa Eastern Cape , Recycling (Waste, etc.) South Africa Eastern Cape , Water reuse South Africa Eastern Cape , Irrigation South Africa Eastern Cape , Sewage Purification Anaerobic treatment , Constructed wetlands , Aquaculture
- Language: English
- Type: Doctoral theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/191126 , vital:45063 , 10.21504/10962/191126
- Description: Water scarcity in South Africa, and globally, presents challenges for industries. It is imperative to develop responsible water use, such as recycling and reusing wastewater from food processing industries such as breweries. The Ibhayi Brewery (SAB Ltd) employs a combination of sustainable treatment processes that include anaerobic digestion (AD), primary facultative ponds (PFP), high rate algal ponds (HRAP) and constructed wetlands (CW) to treat brewery effluent on an experimental scale. The constituent concentrations of these experimentally treated effluents are within the ranges prescribed by local regulations to allow for potential downstream use in agriculture and aquaculture. However, the sodium content in this treated effluent, which originates from upstream cleaning agents and pH control at the onsite effluent treatment facility, is a constraint to the downstream use of brewery effluent. This study addresses the salt problem, by investigating the potential of either reducing/eliminating salt addition at source, or developing alternative techniques for downstream agriculture to mitigate the effects of salt accumulation caused by irrigation with brewery effluent. Four salt-tolerant test crops; Swiss chard (Beta vulgaris), saltbush (Atriplex nummularia), Salicornia meyeriana and sorghum (Sorghum bicolor), grew efficiently in brewery effluent irrigated soils but did not stop sodium accumulation in the growth medium. Swiss chard had the best growth with a wet biomass accumulation of 8,173 g m-2, due to the plant’s ability to tolerate saline conditions and continuous cropping. Crop rotation, to limit effects of nutrient depletion in soil, had no significant effect on plant growth suggesting soils were adequately able to provide micro-nutrients in the short-term. Prolonged irrigation with brewery effluent can lead to sodium accumulation in the soil, which was successfully controlled through the addition of soil amendments (gypsum and Trichoderma cultures). These reduced soil sodium from a potentially limiting level of 1,398 mg L-1 to the acceptable levels of 240 mg L-1 and 353 mg L-1 respectively, mainly through leaching. However only Trichoderma improved Swiss chard production to 11,238 g m-2. While crop rotation in this work did not contribute to mitigating the problem of salt accumulation, soil amended with Trichoderma appears to be a potential solution when brewery effluent is reused in agriculture. In an alternative to soil cultivation, CWs were trialled with no significant differences in the sodium concentration of brewery effluent treated along a 15 m lateral flow CW, which could be attributed to evapotranspiration. This was notably accompanied by a desirable 95.21% decrease in ammonia from inlet to outlet resulting in significant improvement in water quality for reuse in aquaculture where ammonia levels are important limiting constraints. While CWs remain a suitable brewery effluent treatment solution, this technology requires additional modelling and optimisation in order to mitigate the problem of salt accumulation in the reuse of treated brewery effluent in agriculture and aquaculture. This research demonstrates the baseline information for such modelling and optimisation. African catfish (Clarias gariepinus) grew in CW treated brewery effluent; however, this growth was moderate at 0.92% bw day-1, whereas Mozambique tilapia (Oreochromis mossambicus) were shown to be unsuited to growth in this system and lost weight with an average specific growth rate (SGR) of -0.98% bw day-1; and both fish species presenting with health related concerns. Hardy fish species such as African catfish can be cultured in brewery effluent, but with risk involved. This was a preliminary study to develop parameters for future dimensional analysis modelling to allow optimisation of the CW, based on nutrient removal rates obtained which will allow for improved downstream aquaculture by reducing or eliminating risks presented in this study. This work has also contributed to a foundation for the development of guidelines that use a risk-based approach for water use in aquaculture. Alternatives to the current in place cleaning agents were considered to mitigate the effects of salt accumulation. Sodium is introduced into the effluent via the use of sodium hydroxide and sodium chlorite for cleaning and disinfection in the brewery, as well as through effluent pH adjustment in the AD plant. The widespread use of outdated legacy cleaning systems and pH adjustment regimes is entrenched in the brewery standard operating procedures (SOP). A cost-benefit analysis (CBA) demonstrated that a change of cleaning and disinfecting regimes to hydrogen peroxide in the brewery, and magnesium hydroxide pH adjustment in the effluent treatment plant addresses the sodium issue upstream in the brewery practically eliminating sodium from the effluent. In addition, a life cycle analysis (LCA) was carried out to assess the environmental impacts associated with the alternative cleaning and pH adjustment scenarios. The LCA showed that electricity consumption during use phase of the chemicals for respective purposes, as well as their production activities were major contributors to the significant environmental impact categories that were assessed. The cleaning scenario employing the use of hydrogen peroxide for both cleaning and disinfection was found to be the most environmentally sustainable. This was attributed to the reduced number of chemicals used compared to the other cleaning scenarios. Dolomitic lime was the pH adjustment alternative with the lowest average environmental impact; but, however, had a higher impact on freshwater eutrophication which is of major concern if the effluent will be reused for irrigation. Magnesium hydroxide was therefore considered to be the better option as a sodium hydroxide alternative for pH adjustment. This mitigates salt accumulation, making treated brewery effluent suitable for reuse in high value downstream agriculture and aquaculture, while employing more environmentally sustainable technologies. Notably, this converts brewery effluent from a financial liability to Ibhayi Brewery, into a product containing water and nutrients that generate income, improve food security, and can create employment in downstream agriculture and aquaculture in a sustainable manner. , Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Science, Ichthyology and Fisheries Science, 2021
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2021-10-29
- Authors: Mabasa, Nyiko Charity
- Date: 2021-10-29
- Subjects: Brewery waste South Africa Eastern Cape , Recycling (Waste, etc.) South Africa Eastern Cape , Water reuse South Africa Eastern Cape , Irrigation South Africa Eastern Cape , Sewage Purification Anaerobic treatment , Constructed wetlands , Aquaculture
- Language: English
- Type: Doctoral theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/191126 , vital:45063 , 10.21504/10962/191126
- Description: Water scarcity in South Africa, and globally, presents challenges for industries. It is imperative to develop responsible water use, such as recycling and reusing wastewater from food processing industries such as breweries. The Ibhayi Brewery (SAB Ltd) employs a combination of sustainable treatment processes that include anaerobic digestion (AD), primary facultative ponds (PFP), high rate algal ponds (HRAP) and constructed wetlands (CW) to treat brewery effluent on an experimental scale. The constituent concentrations of these experimentally treated effluents are within the ranges prescribed by local regulations to allow for potential downstream use in agriculture and aquaculture. However, the sodium content in this treated effluent, which originates from upstream cleaning agents and pH control at the onsite effluent treatment facility, is a constraint to the downstream use of brewery effluent. This study addresses the salt problem, by investigating the potential of either reducing/eliminating salt addition at source, or developing alternative techniques for downstream agriculture to mitigate the effects of salt accumulation caused by irrigation with brewery effluent. Four salt-tolerant test crops; Swiss chard (Beta vulgaris), saltbush (Atriplex nummularia), Salicornia meyeriana and sorghum (Sorghum bicolor), grew efficiently in brewery effluent irrigated soils but did not stop sodium accumulation in the growth medium. Swiss chard had the best growth with a wet biomass accumulation of 8,173 g m-2, due to the plant’s ability to tolerate saline conditions and continuous cropping. Crop rotation, to limit effects of nutrient depletion in soil, had no significant effect on plant growth suggesting soils were adequately able to provide micro-nutrients in the short-term. Prolonged irrigation with brewery effluent can lead to sodium accumulation in the soil, which was successfully controlled through the addition of soil amendments (gypsum and Trichoderma cultures). These reduced soil sodium from a potentially limiting level of 1,398 mg L-1 to the acceptable levels of 240 mg L-1 and 353 mg L-1 respectively, mainly through leaching. However only Trichoderma improved Swiss chard production to 11,238 g m-2. While crop rotation in this work did not contribute to mitigating the problem of salt accumulation, soil amended with Trichoderma appears to be a potential solution when brewery effluent is reused in agriculture. In an alternative to soil cultivation, CWs were trialled with no significant differences in the sodium concentration of brewery effluent treated along a 15 m lateral flow CW, which could be attributed to evapotranspiration. This was notably accompanied by a desirable 95.21% decrease in ammonia from inlet to outlet resulting in significant improvement in water quality for reuse in aquaculture where ammonia levels are important limiting constraints. While CWs remain a suitable brewery effluent treatment solution, this technology requires additional modelling and optimisation in order to mitigate the problem of salt accumulation in the reuse of treated brewery effluent in agriculture and aquaculture. This research demonstrates the baseline information for such modelling and optimisation. African catfish (Clarias gariepinus) grew in CW treated brewery effluent; however, this growth was moderate at 0.92% bw day-1, whereas Mozambique tilapia (Oreochromis mossambicus) were shown to be unsuited to growth in this system and lost weight with an average specific growth rate (SGR) of -0.98% bw day-1; and both fish species presenting with health related concerns. Hardy fish species such as African catfish can be cultured in brewery effluent, but with risk involved. This was a preliminary study to develop parameters for future dimensional analysis modelling to allow optimisation of the CW, based on nutrient removal rates obtained which will allow for improved downstream aquaculture by reducing or eliminating risks presented in this study. This work has also contributed to a foundation for the development of guidelines that use a risk-based approach for water use in aquaculture. Alternatives to the current in place cleaning agents were considered to mitigate the effects of salt accumulation. Sodium is introduced into the effluent via the use of sodium hydroxide and sodium chlorite for cleaning and disinfection in the brewery, as well as through effluent pH adjustment in the AD plant. The widespread use of outdated legacy cleaning systems and pH adjustment regimes is entrenched in the brewery standard operating procedures (SOP). A cost-benefit analysis (CBA) demonstrated that a change of cleaning and disinfecting regimes to hydrogen peroxide in the brewery, and magnesium hydroxide pH adjustment in the effluent treatment plant addresses the sodium issue upstream in the brewery practically eliminating sodium from the effluent. In addition, a life cycle analysis (LCA) was carried out to assess the environmental impacts associated with the alternative cleaning and pH adjustment scenarios. The LCA showed that electricity consumption during use phase of the chemicals for respective purposes, as well as their production activities were major contributors to the significant environmental impact categories that were assessed. The cleaning scenario employing the use of hydrogen peroxide for both cleaning and disinfection was found to be the most environmentally sustainable. This was attributed to the reduced number of chemicals used compared to the other cleaning scenarios. Dolomitic lime was the pH adjustment alternative with the lowest average environmental impact; but, however, had a higher impact on freshwater eutrophication which is of major concern if the effluent will be reused for irrigation. Magnesium hydroxide was therefore considered to be the better option as a sodium hydroxide alternative for pH adjustment. This mitigates salt accumulation, making treated brewery effluent suitable for reuse in high value downstream agriculture and aquaculture, while employing more environmentally sustainable technologies. Notably, this converts brewery effluent from a financial liability to Ibhayi Brewery, into a product containing water and nutrients that generate income, improve food security, and can create employment in downstream agriculture and aquaculture in a sustainable manner. , Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Science, Ichthyology and Fisheries Science, 2021
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2021-10-29
Settlement and metamorphosis in the veliger larvae of the South African abalone Haliotis midae exposed to ambient grown biofilms treated with conspecific mucous
- Authors: Van Staden, Jefferson Luke
- Date: 2021-10-29
- Subjects: Haliotis midae , Biofilms , Haliotis midae Larvae Behavior , Haliotis midae Metamorphosis , Biosecurity , Aquaculture , Metamorphosis , Attachment mechanisms (Biology) , Mucous
- Language: English
- Type: Master's theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/192187 , vital:45203
- Description: The South African abalone, Haliotis midae, is a commercially important species of mollusc which contributes significantly to the value of the South African mariculture industry. One of the primary challenges experienced by abalone farmers is the consistent production of juvenile abalone (spat) in sufficient volumes to keep stocking farms and facilitate expansion of the industry. One of the key production bottlenecks of H. midae is achieving adequate levels of larval attachment and metamorphosis (settlement). The larvae of H. midae are settled on polycarbonate plates which have been pre-conditioned with biofilms in seawater which is pumped ashore onto farms. The seasonal variability in settlement success reported by hatchery managers in South Africa is hypothesised to be as a result of different diatom species compositions colonising the settlement plates at different times of the year, with settlement success being lowest during the winter months. The following study investigated whether the addition of conspecific mucous to biofilms could result in elevated settlement success, and whether there was potential for sterilisation of this mucous. A novel method of mucous application, spraying it onto the plates as opposed to pre-grazing, was tested in settlement assays and the trials revealed the following results: • The addition of H. midae mucous induced significantly more larvae to attach to settlement plates, when mucous was harvested around the spawning season. • Elevated attachment of larvae on mucous treated plates did not result in more post-larvae occupying the plates at the end of trials, and increased mortality is likely attributed to introduction of pathogens in conjunction with mucous. • No increase in the final proportion of settled larvae which had metamorphosed or the rate at which they metamorphosed was observed between mucous application treatments and biofilm only treatments. Subsequent trials assessed whether methods of mucous handling could reduce the biosecurity risk associated with mucous use, and so mucous was either UV irradiated or autoclaved. These trials revealed the following findings: • No difference in attachment was seen between any treatments, including the untreated mucous. This is contrary to the findings of our initial experiments and illustrates that the attachment-inducing properties within mucous may be seasonally expressed. ii • Numbers of observed larvae/post-larvae on plates applied with UV and autoclaved mucous where less stable than biofilms only, especially in the second trial, illustrating that mucous still presents a biosecurity risk even after undergoing these handling methods as it may act as a substrate on which pathogenic bacteria could colonise. , Thesis (MSc) -- Faculty of Science, Ichthyology and Fisheries Science, 2021
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2021-10-29
- Authors: Van Staden, Jefferson Luke
- Date: 2021-10-29
- Subjects: Haliotis midae , Biofilms , Haliotis midae Larvae Behavior , Haliotis midae Metamorphosis , Biosecurity , Aquaculture , Metamorphosis , Attachment mechanisms (Biology) , Mucous
- Language: English
- Type: Master's theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/192187 , vital:45203
- Description: The South African abalone, Haliotis midae, is a commercially important species of mollusc which contributes significantly to the value of the South African mariculture industry. One of the primary challenges experienced by abalone farmers is the consistent production of juvenile abalone (spat) in sufficient volumes to keep stocking farms and facilitate expansion of the industry. One of the key production bottlenecks of H. midae is achieving adequate levels of larval attachment and metamorphosis (settlement). The larvae of H. midae are settled on polycarbonate plates which have been pre-conditioned with biofilms in seawater which is pumped ashore onto farms. The seasonal variability in settlement success reported by hatchery managers in South Africa is hypothesised to be as a result of different diatom species compositions colonising the settlement plates at different times of the year, with settlement success being lowest during the winter months. The following study investigated whether the addition of conspecific mucous to biofilms could result in elevated settlement success, and whether there was potential for sterilisation of this mucous. A novel method of mucous application, spraying it onto the plates as opposed to pre-grazing, was tested in settlement assays and the trials revealed the following results: • The addition of H. midae mucous induced significantly more larvae to attach to settlement plates, when mucous was harvested around the spawning season. • Elevated attachment of larvae on mucous treated plates did not result in more post-larvae occupying the plates at the end of trials, and increased mortality is likely attributed to introduction of pathogens in conjunction with mucous. • No increase in the final proportion of settled larvae which had metamorphosed or the rate at which they metamorphosed was observed between mucous application treatments and biofilm only treatments. Subsequent trials assessed whether methods of mucous handling could reduce the biosecurity risk associated with mucous use, and so mucous was either UV irradiated or autoclaved. These trials revealed the following findings: • No difference in attachment was seen between any treatments, including the untreated mucous. This is contrary to the findings of our initial experiments and illustrates that the attachment-inducing properties within mucous may be seasonally expressed. ii • Numbers of observed larvae/post-larvae on plates applied with UV and autoclaved mucous where less stable than biofilms only, especially in the second trial, illustrating that mucous still presents a biosecurity risk even after undergoing these handling methods as it may act as a substrate on which pathogenic bacteria could colonise. , Thesis (MSc) -- Faculty of Science, Ichthyology and Fisheries Science, 2021
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2021-10-29
Resource recovery options in brewery effluent treatment using activated sludge and high rate algal ponds: assessing environmental impacts
- Authors: Taylor, Richard Peter
- Date: 2020
- Subjects: Sewage -- Purification -- Activated sludge process , Sewage disposal plants , Sewage -- Purification -- Biological treatament , Sewage -- Purification -- Nitrogen removal , Brewery waste , Breweries -- Waste disposal , Microalgae -- Biotechnology , Algal biofuels
- Language: English
- Type: text , Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/153746 , vital:39507
- Description: Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) are designed to clean effluents, but they also consume resources and produce waste. Various treatment technologies allow for the recovery of energy, nutrients and water from effluents turning this waste into products, which increases their sustainability and decreases the impact of WWTPs on the environment. There is a lack of literature which comprehensively compares the treatment performances, environmental impacts and beneficial downstream uses of the biomass generated by high rate algal pond (HRAP) and activated sludge (AS) treatment systems. This thesis aimed to compare (1) effluent treatment performance, (2) emissions and (3) downstream use of algae cultured in HRAP to sludge produced in AS and to obtain data to conduct a life cycle analysis (LCA) to compare the systems. The focus was on adding value to the effluent treatment process, while identifying the associated environmental impacts and contributing to the first ever zero-waste brewery effluent treatment system. Furthermore, these data were used to provide a basis to critically review and contribute to improving the methods used in the LCA of effluent treatment systems; particularly since this was the first wastewater treatment LCA that compared AS and HRAP using data collected from the same temporal and geographic location and from a single effluent stream. The electrical consumption water emission and land application of waste biomass caused the major environmental impacts of both treatment systems. The HRAP had less than 50 % of the electrical energy consumption (0.11±0.01 kW/m3 of effluent treated) compared to the AS system (0.29±0.11 kW/m3) which resulted in the technology having a lower climate change, photochemical oxidant formation, freshwater and marine ecotoxicity and fossil fuel depletion impact. It is imperative to understand the method of electrical energy (fossil fuel vs renewable) generation when conducting a LCA and deciding which technologies to use, since they have a major influence on the aforementioned impacts. The biogas yield of algal and sludge substrates was similar with an average gas production of 241 ml/g volatile solids fed. Biogas from algae fed digesters had a significantly higher methane content (64.73±0.81 %) and lower carbon dioxide content (22.94±0.24 %) when compared to WAS fed digesters (60.08±0.18 % and 27.37±0.43 %) respectively due to it being a less oxidised substrate. Swiss chard plants (Beta vulgaris) fertilised with anaerobically digested (AD) algae or sludge had a significantly higher mean biweekly yield (5.08±0.73 kg/m2) when compared to the inorganic-fertiliser control (3.45±0.89 kg/m2; p<0.0001). No difference was observed in the soil’s physical fertility when algae or sludge were applied to the soil (p>0.05). The HRAP produced more biomass (317.18±27.76 g/m3) than the AS (83.12±64.91 g/m3), which resulted in a significantly greater downstream production of biogas and fertiliser per volume of effluent treated. According to the LCA, this also resulted in the HRAP system having a higher terrestrial ecotoxicity, due to the greater volume of solids and thus heavy metals applied to the soil. This interpretation can be misleading, because the mass of heavy metals released into the environment is the same for both systems, with a greater portion being applied to the land in the HRAP scenario and discharged into fresh water in the case of AS. Future LCA models should clarify if these biomasses are going to be applied to a single piece of land or multiple sites as this will influence the risk of contamination via pollutant build up in the soil. The application of sludge or algae on soil increased the soil’s sodium concentration and sodium absorption ratio from 774.80±13.66 mg/kg to 952.17±34.89 mg/kg and 2.91±0.04 to 3.53±0.13, respectively. Regulations on the application of algae or sludge on agricultural soils should be altered to consider the limit values for sodium and future LCA’s associated with effluent treatment facilities should incorporate the possibility of soil contamination through sodium build-up. This work also conceptualised the importance of reporting water emissions in wastewater treatment LCA in as much detail as possible, because this had a significant influence on the eutrophication impacts on water systems. Reporting water emissions as total nitrogen underestimated downstream eutrophication impacts compared with those using nitrogen-species concentration (ammonia, nitrite, nitrate etc). A marine eutrophication sensitivity co-efficient should be included in future LCA models which accounts for the probability of nitrogen and phosphorus emissions entering the coastal environment as well as the vulnerability of the marine environment to eutrophication. Activated sludge systems are favourable for situations where space is limited, were there are inadequate options for biomass disposal (biomass not be used in agriculture or AD) and were electricity is generated from a renewable source; whereas, HRAP are more suitable under circumstances where electricity production relies on fossil fuel that carries a high environmental impact and where options are available to use the biomass for economic gain such as biogas and fertiliser production. This thesis contributes towards a zero-waste brewery effluent treated process. The HRAP and AS treated effluent for reuse in the brewery or in agricultural irrigation. The solids were anaerobically digested, and the carbon was recovered as a biogas, while the digestate was applied as an agricultural fertiliser. This allowed for the recovery of water, nutrients and carbon.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2020
- Authors: Taylor, Richard Peter
- Date: 2020
- Subjects: Sewage -- Purification -- Activated sludge process , Sewage disposal plants , Sewage -- Purification -- Biological treatament , Sewage -- Purification -- Nitrogen removal , Brewery waste , Breweries -- Waste disposal , Microalgae -- Biotechnology , Algal biofuels
- Language: English
- Type: text , Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/153746 , vital:39507
- Description: Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) are designed to clean effluents, but they also consume resources and produce waste. Various treatment technologies allow for the recovery of energy, nutrients and water from effluents turning this waste into products, which increases their sustainability and decreases the impact of WWTPs on the environment. There is a lack of literature which comprehensively compares the treatment performances, environmental impacts and beneficial downstream uses of the biomass generated by high rate algal pond (HRAP) and activated sludge (AS) treatment systems. This thesis aimed to compare (1) effluent treatment performance, (2) emissions and (3) downstream use of algae cultured in HRAP to sludge produced in AS and to obtain data to conduct a life cycle analysis (LCA) to compare the systems. The focus was on adding value to the effluent treatment process, while identifying the associated environmental impacts and contributing to the first ever zero-waste brewery effluent treatment system. Furthermore, these data were used to provide a basis to critically review and contribute to improving the methods used in the LCA of effluent treatment systems; particularly since this was the first wastewater treatment LCA that compared AS and HRAP using data collected from the same temporal and geographic location and from a single effluent stream. The electrical consumption water emission and land application of waste biomass caused the major environmental impacts of both treatment systems. The HRAP had less than 50 % of the electrical energy consumption (0.11±0.01 kW/m3 of effluent treated) compared to the AS system (0.29±0.11 kW/m3) which resulted in the technology having a lower climate change, photochemical oxidant formation, freshwater and marine ecotoxicity and fossil fuel depletion impact. It is imperative to understand the method of electrical energy (fossil fuel vs renewable) generation when conducting a LCA and deciding which technologies to use, since they have a major influence on the aforementioned impacts. The biogas yield of algal and sludge substrates was similar with an average gas production of 241 ml/g volatile solids fed. Biogas from algae fed digesters had a significantly higher methane content (64.73±0.81 %) and lower carbon dioxide content (22.94±0.24 %) when compared to WAS fed digesters (60.08±0.18 % and 27.37±0.43 %) respectively due to it being a less oxidised substrate. Swiss chard plants (Beta vulgaris) fertilised with anaerobically digested (AD) algae or sludge had a significantly higher mean biweekly yield (5.08±0.73 kg/m2) when compared to the inorganic-fertiliser control (3.45±0.89 kg/m2; p<0.0001). No difference was observed in the soil’s physical fertility when algae or sludge were applied to the soil (p>0.05). The HRAP produced more biomass (317.18±27.76 g/m3) than the AS (83.12±64.91 g/m3), which resulted in a significantly greater downstream production of biogas and fertiliser per volume of effluent treated. According to the LCA, this also resulted in the HRAP system having a higher terrestrial ecotoxicity, due to the greater volume of solids and thus heavy metals applied to the soil. This interpretation can be misleading, because the mass of heavy metals released into the environment is the same for both systems, with a greater portion being applied to the land in the HRAP scenario and discharged into fresh water in the case of AS. Future LCA models should clarify if these biomasses are going to be applied to a single piece of land or multiple sites as this will influence the risk of contamination via pollutant build up in the soil. The application of sludge or algae on soil increased the soil’s sodium concentration and sodium absorption ratio from 774.80±13.66 mg/kg to 952.17±34.89 mg/kg and 2.91±0.04 to 3.53±0.13, respectively. Regulations on the application of algae or sludge on agricultural soils should be altered to consider the limit values for sodium and future LCA’s associated with effluent treatment facilities should incorporate the possibility of soil contamination through sodium build-up. This work also conceptualised the importance of reporting water emissions in wastewater treatment LCA in as much detail as possible, because this had a significant influence on the eutrophication impacts on water systems. Reporting water emissions as total nitrogen underestimated downstream eutrophication impacts compared with those using nitrogen-species concentration (ammonia, nitrite, nitrate etc). A marine eutrophication sensitivity co-efficient should be included in future LCA models which accounts for the probability of nitrogen and phosphorus emissions entering the coastal environment as well as the vulnerability of the marine environment to eutrophication. Activated sludge systems are favourable for situations where space is limited, were there are inadequate options for biomass disposal (biomass not be used in agriculture or AD) and were electricity is generated from a renewable source; whereas, HRAP are more suitable under circumstances where electricity production relies on fossil fuel that carries a high environmental impact and where options are available to use the biomass for economic gain such as biogas and fertiliser production. This thesis contributes towards a zero-waste brewery effluent treated process. The HRAP and AS treated effluent for reuse in the brewery or in agricultural irrigation. The solids were anaerobically digested, and the carbon was recovered as a biogas, while the digestate was applied as an agricultural fertiliser. This allowed for the recovery of water, nutrients and carbon.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2020
The effect of alginate supplementation on the growth, feed utilization, digestive enzyme activity levels, and intestinal morphology of juvenile South African abalone (Haliotis midae) fed formulated feeds
- Authors: Tlakedi, Thato
- Date: 2020
- Subjects: Abalones -- Feeding and feeds -- South Africa , Haliotis midae , Abalones -- Digestive organs , Abalones -- Morphology
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/145279 , vital:38424
- Description: Alginate occurs abundantly in kelp and while a few studies have quantified the effect of kelp inclusion in formulated Haliotis midae feeds, none have researched the effect of alginate inclusion on the growth of abalone fed this feed. Feeding kelp to cultured abalone affects gut structure and modulates gut bacteria, aiding digestion by upregulating enzyme activity. This farm-based experiment compared the growth, feed utilization, digestive enzyme activity levels and intestinal villi structure between abalone (1-year-old, 10 - 20 mm shell length) fed kelp-supplemented (BK) or alginate-supplemented (BA) diets and abalone fed basal (B) and fresh kelp (K) diets for a period of eight months from June 2017 to February 2018. Growth and enzyme activities were also compared between abalone that experienced dietary changes and abalone that remained on their initial diets. The tested diets were: base diet (B, 34% protein), the same base diet supplemented with fresh minced kelp (0.90% kelp [dry mass, equivalent to 0.20% alginate]; BK), base diet supplemented with sodium alginate (0.20% alginate; BA) and a fresh kelp diet (K). Alginate or kelp inclusion in a formulated feed had no significant effect on the specific growth rates (SGR), linear shell growth rates (LGR), daily percentage feeding rates (PFR), feed conversion ratio (FCR), percentage mass gain (MG) and condition factor (CF) over the eight month trial period, compared to abalone fed the base diet. In October 2017, four months since the start of the trial in June, all the groups fed formulated feeds showed significantly higher average weight gain (8.42 ± 0.72 g to 8.86 ± 0.63 g) compared to the kelp-fed group (6.68 ± 0.43 g). However, no significant differences in the average weight gain were observed between abalone fed kelp and formulated feeds at the end of this study. Furthermore, there were no significant differences in the FCR and PFR between abalone fed the base or alginate diets and abalone fed the fresh kelp diet. However, the SW diet produced significantly lower FCR (1.00 ± 0.13) and PFR (0.78 ± 0.10%) compared to the kelp diet (10.6 ± 1.40% and 8.12 ± 1.01%, respectively). All formulated diets produced non-significant LGR, MG and CF compared to the kelp diet at the end of this study. Enzyme activity levels were compared between abalone fed the test diets in July and August 2017 and February 2018. There were no significant differences in the average alginate lyase specific activity levels between abalone fed formulated diets in July and August 2017. At the end of the trial, however, the alginate diet induced significantly higher alginate lyase specific activity levels (4.89 ± 1.64 mg.mg-1 protein) compared to the base diet (1.57 ± 0.98 mg.mg-1 protein), but showed no significant differences compared to the SW (3.78 ± 0.41 mg.mg-1 protein) and fresh kelp-only diets (4.00 ± 0.62 mg.mg-1 protein). The SW diet showed no significant differences in the alginate lyase specific activity levels compared to the base diet. There were no significant differences in the chymotrypsin activity levels between the test diets throughout this study. Alginate or kelp inclusion also had no significant effect on the intestinal structure compared to the base or fresh kelp diets. This was despite a higher degree of variability in microvilli height and width being observed in abalone fed the kelp-only diet, with microvilli visibly wider and longer than in abalone fed formulated feeds. Switching abalone between some diets significantly affected the average weight gain, MG, FCR and PFR, alginate lyase, chymotrypsin and cellulase activity levels compared to abalone kept on their initial diets. The inclusion levels of kelp and alginate used in this study were likely too low to affect abalone growth as higher inclusion levels, particularly of alginate, have been found to improve fish growth. This study concluded that minced kelp and alginate inclusion in a formulated H. midae diet did not affect the SGR, FCR and intestinal morphology, but significantly affected alginate lyase and chymotrypsin activity levels. Furthermore, changes in growth and digestive enzyme activity levels coincided with dietary changes. Consequently, higher inclusion levels, particularly of sodium alginate, and the effect of dietary changes on abalone growth and digestive enzymes must be investigated in future studies.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2020
- Authors: Tlakedi, Thato
- Date: 2020
- Subjects: Abalones -- Feeding and feeds -- South Africa , Haliotis midae , Abalones -- Digestive organs , Abalones -- Morphology
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/145279 , vital:38424
- Description: Alginate occurs abundantly in kelp and while a few studies have quantified the effect of kelp inclusion in formulated Haliotis midae feeds, none have researched the effect of alginate inclusion on the growth of abalone fed this feed. Feeding kelp to cultured abalone affects gut structure and modulates gut bacteria, aiding digestion by upregulating enzyme activity. This farm-based experiment compared the growth, feed utilization, digestive enzyme activity levels and intestinal villi structure between abalone (1-year-old, 10 - 20 mm shell length) fed kelp-supplemented (BK) or alginate-supplemented (BA) diets and abalone fed basal (B) and fresh kelp (K) diets for a period of eight months from June 2017 to February 2018. Growth and enzyme activities were also compared between abalone that experienced dietary changes and abalone that remained on their initial diets. The tested diets were: base diet (B, 34% protein), the same base diet supplemented with fresh minced kelp (0.90% kelp [dry mass, equivalent to 0.20% alginate]; BK), base diet supplemented with sodium alginate (0.20% alginate; BA) and a fresh kelp diet (K). Alginate or kelp inclusion in a formulated feed had no significant effect on the specific growth rates (SGR), linear shell growth rates (LGR), daily percentage feeding rates (PFR), feed conversion ratio (FCR), percentage mass gain (MG) and condition factor (CF) over the eight month trial period, compared to abalone fed the base diet. In October 2017, four months since the start of the trial in June, all the groups fed formulated feeds showed significantly higher average weight gain (8.42 ± 0.72 g to 8.86 ± 0.63 g) compared to the kelp-fed group (6.68 ± 0.43 g). However, no significant differences in the average weight gain were observed between abalone fed kelp and formulated feeds at the end of this study. Furthermore, there were no significant differences in the FCR and PFR between abalone fed the base or alginate diets and abalone fed the fresh kelp diet. However, the SW diet produced significantly lower FCR (1.00 ± 0.13) and PFR (0.78 ± 0.10%) compared to the kelp diet (10.6 ± 1.40% and 8.12 ± 1.01%, respectively). All formulated diets produced non-significant LGR, MG and CF compared to the kelp diet at the end of this study. Enzyme activity levels were compared between abalone fed the test diets in July and August 2017 and February 2018. There were no significant differences in the average alginate lyase specific activity levels between abalone fed formulated diets in July and August 2017. At the end of the trial, however, the alginate diet induced significantly higher alginate lyase specific activity levels (4.89 ± 1.64 mg.mg-1 protein) compared to the base diet (1.57 ± 0.98 mg.mg-1 protein), but showed no significant differences compared to the SW (3.78 ± 0.41 mg.mg-1 protein) and fresh kelp-only diets (4.00 ± 0.62 mg.mg-1 protein). The SW diet showed no significant differences in the alginate lyase specific activity levels compared to the base diet. There were no significant differences in the chymotrypsin activity levels between the test diets throughout this study. Alginate or kelp inclusion also had no significant effect on the intestinal structure compared to the base or fresh kelp diets. This was despite a higher degree of variability in microvilli height and width being observed in abalone fed the kelp-only diet, with microvilli visibly wider and longer than in abalone fed formulated feeds. Switching abalone between some diets significantly affected the average weight gain, MG, FCR and PFR, alginate lyase, chymotrypsin and cellulase activity levels compared to abalone kept on their initial diets. The inclusion levels of kelp and alginate used in this study were likely too low to affect abalone growth as higher inclusion levels, particularly of alginate, have been found to improve fish growth. This study concluded that minced kelp and alginate inclusion in a formulated H. midae diet did not affect the SGR, FCR and intestinal morphology, but significantly affected alginate lyase and chymotrypsin activity levels. Furthermore, changes in growth and digestive enzyme activity levels coincided with dietary changes. Consequently, higher inclusion levels, particularly of sodium alginate, and the effect of dietary changes on abalone growth and digestive enzymes must be investigated in future studies.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2020
Apparent digestibility coefficients of feed ingredients and essential amino acid requirements of dusky kob (Argyrosomus japonicus)
- Authors: Adesola, Abidemi Adejoke
- Date: 2017
- Subjects: Amino acids in animal nutrition , Fishes -- Feeding and feeds , Argyrosomus japonicus , Argyrosomus , Argyrosomus japonicus -- Nutrition , Argyrosomus -- Nutrition , Argyrosomus japonicus -- Feeding and feeds , Argyrosomus -- Feeding and feeds
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/32140 , vital:24014
- Description: Important to the evaluation of potential feed ingredients for inclusion in fish diets should be their digestibility and amino acid requirement so that feeds can be formulated on a digestible basis rather than a gross nutrient basis. This thesis established techniques for faecal collection, the validity of digestibility markers, it determined apparent digestibility coefficients for various novel feed ingredients, and it established the optimal lysine requirement for Argyrosomus japonicus, which was used to estimate each of the essential amino acid requirements by using the ideal protein concept. There were no significant differences in dry matter apparent digestibility coefficients when faeces were collected by stripping (77.0 %), dissection (80.1 %) or settlement (83.5 %). Faecal collection by the settlement method produced the most reliable digestibility data. Apparent digestibility coefficients for dry matter, crude protein and energy calculated using acid-insoluble ash were higher (84.0 %, 93.2 % and 93.0 %, respectively) than those using chromic oxide (55.7 %, 79.1 % and 78.2 %) and titanium dioxide (58.6 %, 79.7 % and 80.5 %). The magnitude of variation in digestibility coefficients obtained using acid-insoluble ash was always lower than that obtained with the other markers. Therefore, acid-insoluble ash was preferred as a dietary marker. Using the above protocol, protein and amino acid digestibility of some animal and plant protein ingredients were evaluated in a series of experiments. The first trial compared the apparent digestibility coefficients of some animal products included as single protein source in the test diets. Apparent protein digestibility values were 84.5 %, 83.8 %, 85.8 % and 83.1 % for fishmeal-prime, fishmeal-standard, poultry meal and pork meal, respectively. Apparent digestibility coefficients for poultry meal were comparable to those of fishmeal, which indicate its potential as a substitute for fishmeal in the diets of A. japonicus. The second trial determined the apparent coefficients of plant and animal protein sources included at 30 % into a practical reference diet (70 %). Apparent protein digestibility ranged from 92.4 % in sunflower meal to 85.5 % in corn gluten meal. Soybean meal is a promising feed ingredient in A. japonicus due to the high apparent digestibility of its protein (92.0 %) and essential amino acid digestibility (mean average 91.4 %). A fundamental assumption in fish feed formulation is that the digestibility of nutrients is additive, i.e., digestibility of a nutrient in one ingredient does not interact with the digestibility of the same nutrient in another ingredient. In the third trial, additivity of feed ingredients was tested using pork meal and poultry meal. The results indicate that the apparent digestibility coefficient of animal protein ingredients could be calculated from compound diets to accurately determine protein and amino acid digestibility in A. japonicus, and possibly other carnivorous fish species. Dietary essential amino acid requirements were determined for juvenile A. japonicus in two trials. A dose-response study was conducted using crystalline lysine to determine the optimal requirement of dietary lysine for A. japonicus. Optimal dietary lysine was estimated at 31.7 g kg-¹ dry diet, corresponding to 73.5 g kg-¹ of dietary protein, based on specific growth rate and broken-line segmented regression analyses. Dietary requirements for other essential amino acids ranged from 22 g kg-¹ (histidine) to 71 g kg-¹ (leucine) crude protein. The results of the present study provided a research tool that could be used to assess and verify the conclusions of earlier dietary work on A. japonicus and in further studies to develop least cost diet formulations for this species. The study also adds to the knowledge of the nutritional requirements of A. japonicus by providing information on the digestibility of plants and animal protein ingredients. It also contributes to future dietary research for this species because this study determines, for the first time, the most suitable methods for investigating the digestibility of raw materials for A. japonicus.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2017
- Authors: Adesola, Abidemi Adejoke
- Date: 2017
- Subjects: Amino acids in animal nutrition , Fishes -- Feeding and feeds , Argyrosomus japonicus , Argyrosomus , Argyrosomus japonicus -- Nutrition , Argyrosomus -- Nutrition , Argyrosomus japonicus -- Feeding and feeds , Argyrosomus -- Feeding and feeds
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/32140 , vital:24014
- Description: Important to the evaluation of potential feed ingredients for inclusion in fish diets should be their digestibility and amino acid requirement so that feeds can be formulated on a digestible basis rather than a gross nutrient basis. This thesis established techniques for faecal collection, the validity of digestibility markers, it determined apparent digestibility coefficients for various novel feed ingredients, and it established the optimal lysine requirement for Argyrosomus japonicus, which was used to estimate each of the essential amino acid requirements by using the ideal protein concept. There were no significant differences in dry matter apparent digestibility coefficients when faeces were collected by stripping (77.0 %), dissection (80.1 %) or settlement (83.5 %). Faecal collection by the settlement method produced the most reliable digestibility data. Apparent digestibility coefficients for dry matter, crude protein and energy calculated using acid-insoluble ash were higher (84.0 %, 93.2 % and 93.0 %, respectively) than those using chromic oxide (55.7 %, 79.1 % and 78.2 %) and titanium dioxide (58.6 %, 79.7 % and 80.5 %). The magnitude of variation in digestibility coefficients obtained using acid-insoluble ash was always lower than that obtained with the other markers. Therefore, acid-insoluble ash was preferred as a dietary marker. Using the above protocol, protein and amino acid digestibility of some animal and plant protein ingredients were evaluated in a series of experiments. The first trial compared the apparent digestibility coefficients of some animal products included as single protein source in the test diets. Apparent protein digestibility values were 84.5 %, 83.8 %, 85.8 % and 83.1 % for fishmeal-prime, fishmeal-standard, poultry meal and pork meal, respectively. Apparent digestibility coefficients for poultry meal were comparable to those of fishmeal, which indicate its potential as a substitute for fishmeal in the diets of A. japonicus. The second trial determined the apparent coefficients of plant and animal protein sources included at 30 % into a practical reference diet (70 %). Apparent protein digestibility ranged from 92.4 % in sunflower meal to 85.5 % in corn gluten meal. Soybean meal is a promising feed ingredient in A. japonicus due to the high apparent digestibility of its protein (92.0 %) and essential amino acid digestibility (mean average 91.4 %). A fundamental assumption in fish feed formulation is that the digestibility of nutrients is additive, i.e., digestibility of a nutrient in one ingredient does not interact with the digestibility of the same nutrient in another ingredient. In the third trial, additivity of feed ingredients was tested using pork meal and poultry meal. The results indicate that the apparent digestibility coefficient of animal protein ingredients could be calculated from compound diets to accurately determine protein and amino acid digestibility in A. japonicus, and possibly other carnivorous fish species. Dietary essential amino acid requirements were determined for juvenile A. japonicus in two trials. A dose-response study was conducted using crystalline lysine to determine the optimal requirement of dietary lysine for A. japonicus. Optimal dietary lysine was estimated at 31.7 g kg-¹ dry diet, corresponding to 73.5 g kg-¹ of dietary protein, based on specific growth rate and broken-line segmented regression analyses. Dietary requirements for other essential amino acids ranged from 22 g kg-¹ (histidine) to 71 g kg-¹ (leucine) crude protein. The results of the present study provided a research tool that could be used to assess and verify the conclusions of earlier dietary work on A. japonicus and in further studies to develop least cost diet formulations for this species. The study also adds to the knowledge of the nutritional requirements of A. japonicus by providing information on the digestibility of plants and animal protein ingredients. It also contributes to future dietary research for this species because this study determines, for the first time, the most suitable methods for investigating the digestibility of raw materials for A. japonicus.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2017
- «
- ‹
- 1
- ›
- »