Towards a better understanding of small-scale fishing decisions and their consequences in Northern Mozambique
- Authors: Heckendorn, Katrina Ann
- Date: 2023-10-13
- Subjects: Uncatalogued
- Language: English
- Type: Academic theses , Doctoral theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/431797 , vital:72805 , DOI 10.21504/10962/431797
- Description: This study investigates the relationship between the interacting social and ecological systems within the Pemba Bay fishery, in Northern Mozambique, as mediated by fishing decisions. All ecosystems in the world are affected by human behaviours in some way. In many cases, human effects on ecosystems are detrimental to many other species and can cause shifts in the entire system. In fisheries, the connections between human behaviours and ecosystems are obvious, as fishers extract wild populations of marine species. Human behavioural plasticity and sometimes rapid cultural evolution allow human behaviours to change and adapt faster than many other species can respond which often allows fishers to overexploit marine ecosystems. Many fisheries in the world are fully, or over exploited. Managing these fisheries often focuses on changing those highly adaptable human behaviours. Fishers’ motivations for making different fishing decisions as well as attitudes towards the fishery can be used to understand human interactions with ecosystems when the dependence between the two is direct, as well as allowing managers to tailor interventions that account for fishers’ motivations and attitudes. Most fisheries’ management projects assume that behaviours are motivated by profit maximization. This study investigates this assumption by comparing the compatibility of interview responses and fishing behaviours with rational actor theory, which assumes profit maximization is the only goal. Responses are also compared with prospect theory, which emphasizes reliability of outcomes; descriptive norms, which focuses on social interactions; habitual behaviour, which assumes most decision are automatic based on habit; and theory of planned behaviour, which allows attitudes to be shaped by economic or non-economic motivations, as well as peer opinion and incorporates perceived behavioural control in making decisions. These behavioural theories span a variety of potential fisher motivations which could affect fishing decisions. The study then investigates the state of the social and ecological systems which have resulted, at least in part, from those fishing decisions, and makes recommendations on possible interventions to improve the system based on better understanding of fishers’ attitudes and motivations. The study tests the hypothesis that fishers are motivated primarily by profit maximization and, therefore, rational actor theory is most compatible with fishers’ stated motivations for fishing, or alternatively, that one of the other behavioural theories better explains fisher responses. This section used categorized interview responses based on their agreement, or not, with assumed responses if a particular behavioural theory were compatible. The results indicate that four of the five theories are most compatible with responses for at least one fisher, but that the theory of planned behaviour is the most consistent with the data overall, not rational actor theory. Specifically, fishers seem concerned with behavioural control as well as some non-catch related characteristics of the fishery, such as collective action and sustainability. The second hypothesis is that prospect theory is more compatible with current fishing behaviours than rational actor theory. Prospect theory states that people prefer more reliable outcomes, even if slightly less profitable, than outcomes which are more profitable on average, but also more variable. This section used catch data, and changes in relative use of different fishing methods to address this hypothesis. This hypothesis is confirmed for some aspects of fishery data, but not all. Fishers prefer methods which are more reliable and these methods are increasing in relative use. However, neither catch value nor reliability increases fishers’ opinions of their fishing method, but fisher characteristics which increase options do. This again indicates that behavioural control is important in determining fishers’ attitudes towards fishing. The third question addresses the social system within the fishery. It investigates whether fishing in Pemba Bay is a chosen profession or a livelihood of desperation from the poorest individuals. The study hypothesizes that fishers are as well-off as their non-fishing neighbours, and fishers who use more reliable or profitable methods are better off than those using less reliable/profitable methods and, as such, are more committed to fishing as a way of life. This section used fisher interview responses and household surveys to compare subjective and material wellbeing of fishers and non-fishers around Pemba Bay. The first part of the hypothesis is partly supported. Fishers using most methods have material standards of living comparable to non-fishers. However, they report lower subjective well-beings. Most measures of wellbeing are not affected by the reliability or profitability of the fishing method used, which does not support the second part of the hypothesis. Additionally, fishers using more profitable or reliable methods do not indicate more commitment to fishing as a way of life. The fourth and final section investigates the marine ecosystem. Based on conversations with fishers and local researchers, it is assumed that the Pemba fishery is overexploited. As such, the study hypothesizes that marine biomass, individual size of marine species, and functional diversity are lower in Pemba Bay than in other sites around Northern Mozambique, Vamizi Island, Situ Island, and Nuarro, due to high fishing pressure, and that direct removal of species by fishing has a dominant effect. This final section used baited remote underwater videos (BRUVs) to compare species composition and indices of abundance from the different locations. Again, there is support for part of this hypothesis. Marine species biomass and sizes are lower in Pemba Bay than other sites in Northern Mozambique; however, functional diversity is not different. In these data, changes in biomass and size are not correlated with amount of catch, so direct removal by fishing may not be the dominant source of change in the Pemba fishery. Together, these data indicate that the Pemba fishery may be unsustainable based on social and ecological indications. The importance of behavioural control in understanding fishing decisions indicates that any interventions to mitigate problems in the fishery will need to work with fishers to increase empowerment and allow experimentation to find locally relevant solutions to problems. , Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Science, Ichthyology and Fisheries Science, 2023
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2023-10-13
- Authors: Heckendorn, Katrina Ann
- Date: 2023-10-13
- Subjects: Uncatalogued
- Language: English
- Type: Academic theses , Doctoral theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/431797 , vital:72805 , DOI 10.21504/10962/431797
- Description: This study investigates the relationship between the interacting social and ecological systems within the Pemba Bay fishery, in Northern Mozambique, as mediated by fishing decisions. All ecosystems in the world are affected by human behaviours in some way. In many cases, human effects on ecosystems are detrimental to many other species and can cause shifts in the entire system. In fisheries, the connections between human behaviours and ecosystems are obvious, as fishers extract wild populations of marine species. Human behavioural plasticity and sometimes rapid cultural evolution allow human behaviours to change and adapt faster than many other species can respond which often allows fishers to overexploit marine ecosystems. Many fisheries in the world are fully, or over exploited. Managing these fisheries often focuses on changing those highly adaptable human behaviours. Fishers’ motivations for making different fishing decisions as well as attitudes towards the fishery can be used to understand human interactions with ecosystems when the dependence between the two is direct, as well as allowing managers to tailor interventions that account for fishers’ motivations and attitudes. Most fisheries’ management projects assume that behaviours are motivated by profit maximization. This study investigates this assumption by comparing the compatibility of interview responses and fishing behaviours with rational actor theory, which assumes profit maximization is the only goal. Responses are also compared with prospect theory, which emphasizes reliability of outcomes; descriptive norms, which focuses on social interactions; habitual behaviour, which assumes most decision are automatic based on habit; and theory of planned behaviour, which allows attitudes to be shaped by economic or non-economic motivations, as well as peer opinion and incorporates perceived behavioural control in making decisions. These behavioural theories span a variety of potential fisher motivations which could affect fishing decisions. The study then investigates the state of the social and ecological systems which have resulted, at least in part, from those fishing decisions, and makes recommendations on possible interventions to improve the system based on better understanding of fishers’ attitudes and motivations. The study tests the hypothesis that fishers are motivated primarily by profit maximization and, therefore, rational actor theory is most compatible with fishers’ stated motivations for fishing, or alternatively, that one of the other behavioural theories better explains fisher responses. This section used categorized interview responses based on their agreement, or not, with assumed responses if a particular behavioural theory were compatible. The results indicate that four of the five theories are most compatible with responses for at least one fisher, but that the theory of planned behaviour is the most consistent with the data overall, not rational actor theory. Specifically, fishers seem concerned with behavioural control as well as some non-catch related characteristics of the fishery, such as collective action and sustainability. The second hypothesis is that prospect theory is more compatible with current fishing behaviours than rational actor theory. Prospect theory states that people prefer more reliable outcomes, even if slightly less profitable, than outcomes which are more profitable on average, but also more variable. This section used catch data, and changes in relative use of different fishing methods to address this hypothesis. This hypothesis is confirmed for some aspects of fishery data, but not all. Fishers prefer methods which are more reliable and these methods are increasing in relative use. However, neither catch value nor reliability increases fishers’ opinions of their fishing method, but fisher characteristics which increase options do. This again indicates that behavioural control is important in determining fishers’ attitudes towards fishing. The third question addresses the social system within the fishery. It investigates whether fishing in Pemba Bay is a chosen profession or a livelihood of desperation from the poorest individuals. The study hypothesizes that fishers are as well-off as their non-fishing neighbours, and fishers who use more reliable or profitable methods are better off than those using less reliable/profitable methods and, as such, are more committed to fishing as a way of life. This section used fisher interview responses and household surveys to compare subjective and material wellbeing of fishers and non-fishers around Pemba Bay. The first part of the hypothesis is partly supported. Fishers using most methods have material standards of living comparable to non-fishers. However, they report lower subjective well-beings. Most measures of wellbeing are not affected by the reliability or profitability of the fishing method used, which does not support the second part of the hypothesis. Additionally, fishers using more profitable or reliable methods do not indicate more commitment to fishing as a way of life. The fourth and final section investigates the marine ecosystem. Based on conversations with fishers and local researchers, it is assumed that the Pemba fishery is overexploited. As such, the study hypothesizes that marine biomass, individual size of marine species, and functional diversity are lower in Pemba Bay than in other sites around Northern Mozambique, Vamizi Island, Situ Island, and Nuarro, due to high fishing pressure, and that direct removal of species by fishing has a dominant effect. This final section used baited remote underwater videos (BRUVs) to compare species composition and indices of abundance from the different locations. Again, there is support for part of this hypothesis. Marine species biomass and sizes are lower in Pemba Bay than other sites in Northern Mozambique; however, functional diversity is not different. In these data, changes in biomass and size are not correlated with amount of catch, so direct removal by fishing may not be the dominant source of change in the Pemba fishery. Together, these data indicate that the Pemba fishery may be unsustainable based on social and ecological indications. The importance of behavioural control in understanding fishing decisions indicates that any interventions to mitigate problems in the fishery will need to work with fishers to increase empowerment and allow experimentation to find locally relevant solutions to problems. , Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Science, Ichthyology and Fisheries Science, 2023
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2023-10-13
Economically important cephalopods of southern Angola, with a focus on the artisanal jig fishery
- Vázquez Morán, Chénelle Lesley
- Authors: Vázquez Morán, Chénelle Lesley
- Date: 2023-03-31
- Subjects: Uncatalogued
- Language: English
- Type: Academic theses , Doctoral theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/422529 , vital:71955 , DOI 10.21504/10962/422529
- Description: The global decline in marine finfish stocks has been met with a concomitant expansion of fisheries for cephalopods. Despite the increase in the exploitation and commercialization of cephalopods, there is a dearth of scientific information for over 90% of the extant species and this is even more marked in the developing world. Angolan capture fisheries production noted a tenfold increase in cephalopod landings between 1994 and 2003. One of the important fisheries is a cephalopod directed jig fishery that targets the squid Loligo reynaudii and the cuttlefish Sepia vermiculata in southern Angola, however, there is a complete lack of socio-ecological information available for this fishery. Hence the aim of this thesis was to provide basic biological and demographic information on L. reynaudii and S. vermiculata distributed off the coast of southern Angola, assess the importance and dependence of local artisanal fishers on these two species and examine the current management strategies and policies in the region This study found that the artisanal cephalopod jig fishery is critical for the livelihoods of the coastal communities of southern Angola, particularly due to the limited alternative income generating opportunities available. The cephalopod jig fishery is highly labour intensive, with fishers spending a considerable amount of time per day, drifting over known fishing grounds. Catch composition of the artisanal jig fishery indicated that squid is the dominant species within the fishery, in terms of numerical abundance and weight. The productivity and progression of the fishery is hampered by a number of ecological, socio-economic and governance constraints, as highlighted by socio-economic surveys conducted with local squid fishers. Such constraints include, but are not limited to declining catches, increased negative interactions with seals, increased inter-sector competition, lack of infrastructure, poor quality fishing equipment as well as a lack of communication and support from government officials. To examine aspects of the biology and demography of L. reynaudii, whole specimens were collected monthly, from the two primary fishing areas in southern Angola; Namibe and Tombua, during two main sampling periods, June 2008 – May 2009 (Period 1) and June 2014 – May 2015 (Period 2). Male L. reynaudii were found to be significantly larger in size and weight than females, however both the average and maximum dorsal mantle length (DML) decreased between sampling periods. Length-at-50% maturity was larger for male L. reynaudii (170.47 mm DML – 1st period, 165.44 mm DML – 2nd period) than female L. reynaudii (114.71 mm DML – 1st period, 109.43 mm DML – 2nd period). Gonadosomatic indices (GSI) varied significantly during month and season for both sexes. Peak GSI coincided with a low catches in the artisanal jig fishery suggesting that the population may undergo a spawning migration away from fishing grounds, during late spring and summer. The theory of a seasonal spawning migration is further supported in this study by the low abundance of juvenile and sub-adult L, reynaudii collected during the study, along with the inability to detect egg beds in known fishing grounds. Stomach content analysis indicated that teleosts were the most important dietary item (66.3% F of the stomach contents). Trachurus capensis and Engraulis encrasicolus are both highly abundant small pelagic fishes in the cold nutrient rich waters of the Benguela Current and dominated the diet of sampled squid during autumn and winter months. It is likely that the prevalence of large, adult squid off the coast of Angola, as observed within the current study, may be ascribed to the suitable environmental conditions and the abundance of suitable prey. The results from the current study indicate that the southern Angolan subpopulation reveals similarities to that of the West Coast subpopulation of squid in South Africa, with regards to demographics and reproductive characteristics. It is likely that the population in southern Angola is an extension of the South African subpopulation of L. reynaudii on the western extremities. To examine the basic population biology and ecology of S. vermiculata off southern Angola whole specimens were collected from the fishery between December 2014 and April 2015. Morphological results indicate clear sexual dimorphism in soft part characteristics, cuttlebone and beak morphometry. Length-at-50% maturity was smaller in male S. vermiculata (217.53 mm DML) than female S. vermiculata (231.13 mm DML), although these differences were not significant. Stomach content analysis indicated that S. vermiculata predominantly fed on teleost species which were found within 64.5% of stomachs. Teleosts were more dominant in the diet of male S. vermiculata (78.6% F) than female S. vermiculata (53.0% F), which ate a more varied diet including crustaceans (41.2% F) and cephalopods (17.7% F). Availability and abundance of cuttlefish in Namibe indicates that the species may undergo a spatio-temporal shift in distribution, with majority of the artisanal catches of S. vermiculata occurring during summer months. The results from the current study highlights the fisheries potential of L. reynaudii and S. vermiculata and the dependence of artisanal fishers in southern Angola on cephalopods, and more specifically squid. The development of sustainable fisheries management strategies for the artisanal cephalopod jig fishery is critical, particularly as the global exploitation of cephalopods continues to increase with declining finfish populations. Failure to implement management strategies may remove this critical economic safety net for vulnerable coastal communities which have little alternative livelihood opportunities. Ongoing ecological research, a co-management approach and an increased consideration of local ecological knowledge will assist in designing appropriate management plans for the southern Angolan cephalopod jig fishery. , Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Science, Ichthyology and Fisheries Science, 2023
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2023-03-31
- Authors: Vázquez Morán, Chénelle Lesley
- Date: 2023-03-31
- Subjects: Uncatalogued
- Language: English
- Type: Academic theses , Doctoral theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/422529 , vital:71955 , DOI 10.21504/10962/422529
- Description: The global decline in marine finfish stocks has been met with a concomitant expansion of fisheries for cephalopods. Despite the increase in the exploitation and commercialization of cephalopods, there is a dearth of scientific information for over 90% of the extant species and this is even more marked in the developing world. Angolan capture fisheries production noted a tenfold increase in cephalopod landings between 1994 and 2003. One of the important fisheries is a cephalopod directed jig fishery that targets the squid Loligo reynaudii and the cuttlefish Sepia vermiculata in southern Angola, however, there is a complete lack of socio-ecological information available for this fishery. Hence the aim of this thesis was to provide basic biological and demographic information on L. reynaudii and S. vermiculata distributed off the coast of southern Angola, assess the importance and dependence of local artisanal fishers on these two species and examine the current management strategies and policies in the region This study found that the artisanal cephalopod jig fishery is critical for the livelihoods of the coastal communities of southern Angola, particularly due to the limited alternative income generating opportunities available. The cephalopod jig fishery is highly labour intensive, with fishers spending a considerable amount of time per day, drifting over known fishing grounds. Catch composition of the artisanal jig fishery indicated that squid is the dominant species within the fishery, in terms of numerical abundance and weight. The productivity and progression of the fishery is hampered by a number of ecological, socio-economic and governance constraints, as highlighted by socio-economic surveys conducted with local squid fishers. Such constraints include, but are not limited to declining catches, increased negative interactions with seals, increased inter-sector competition, lack of infrastructure, poor quality fishing equipment as well as a lack of communication and support from government officials. To examine aspects of the biology and demography of L. reynaudii, whole specimens were collected monthly, from the two primary fishing areas in southern Angola; Namibe and Tombua, during two main sampling periods, June 2008 – May 2009 (Period 1) and June 2014 – May 2015 (Period 2). Male L. reynaudii were found to be significantly larger in size and weight than females, however both the average and maximum dorsal mantle length (DML) decreased between sampling periods. Length-at-50% maturity was larger for male L. reynaudii (170.47 mm DML – 1st period, 165.44 mm DML – 2nd period) than female L. reynaudii (114.71 mm DML – 1st period, 109.43 mm DML – 2nd period). Gonadosomatic indices (GSI) varied significantly during month and season for both sexes. Peak GSI coincided with a low catches in the artisanal jig fishery suggesting that the population may undergo a spawning migration away from fishing grounds, during late spring and summer. The theory of a seasonal spawning migration is further supported in this study by the low abundance of juvenile and sub-adult L, reynaudii collected during the study, along with the inability to detect egg beds in known fishing grounds. Stomach content analysis indicated that teleosts were the most important dietary item (66.3% F of the stomach contents). Trachurus capensis and Engraulis encrasicolus are both highly abundant small pelagic fishes in the cold nutrient rich waters of the Benguela Current and dominated the diet of sampled squid during autumn and winter months. It is likely that the prevalence of large, adult squid off the coast of Angola, as observed within the current study, may be ascribed to the suitable environmental conditions and the abundance of suitable prey. The results from the current study indicate that the southern Angolan subpopulation reveals similarities to that of the West Coast subpopulation of squid in South Africa, with regards to demographics and reproductive characteristics. It is likely that the population in southern Angola is an extension of the South African subpopulation of L. reynaudii on the western extremities. To examine the basic population biology and ecology of S. vermiculata off southern Angola whole specimens were collected from the fishery between December 2014 and April 2015. Morphological results indicate clear sexual dimorphism in soft part characteristics, cuttlebone and beak morphometry. Length-at-50% maturity was smaller in male S. vermiculata (217.53 mm DML) than female S. vermiculata (231.13 mm DML), although these differences were not significant. Stomach content analysis indicated that S. vermiculata predominantly fed on teleost species which were found within 64.5% of stomachs. Teleosts were more dominant in the diet of male S. vermiculata (78.6% F) than female S. vermiculata (53.0% F), which ate a more varied diet including crustaceans (41.2% F) and cephalopods (17.7% F). Availability and abundance of cuttlefish in Namibe indicates that the species may undergo a spatio-temporal shift in distribution, with majority of the artisanal catches of S. vermiculata occurring during summer months. The results from the current study highlights the fisheries potential of L. reynaudii and S. vermiculata and the dependence of artisanal fishers in southern Angola on cephalopods, and more specifically squid. The development of sustainable fisheries management strategies for the artisanal cephalopod jig fishery is critical, particularly as the global exploitation of cephalopods continues to increase with declining finfish populations. Failure to implement management strategies may remove this critical economic safety net for vulnerable coastal communities which have little alternative livelihood opportunities. Ongoing ecological research, a co-management approach and an increased consideration of local ecological knowledge will assist in designing appropriate management plans for the southern Angolan cephalopod jig fishery. , Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Science, Ichthyology and Fisheries Science, 2023
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2023-03-31
- «
- ‹
- 1
- ›
- »