Prioritising biological control agents for release against Sporobolus pyramidalis and Sporobolus natalensis (Poaceae) in Australia
- Authors: Sutton, Guy Frederick
- Date: 2021
- Subjects: Grasses -- Diseases and pests , Bruchophagus , Wasps , Alien plants -- Biological control -- Australia , Sporobolus -- Biological control -- Africa , Sporobolus -- Biological control -- Australia , Insects as biological pest control agents -- Australia , Insects as biological pest control agents -- Africa
- Language: English
- Type: text , Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/172445 , vital:42201 , 10.21504/10962/172445
- Description: Sporobolus pyramidalis Beauv. and S. natalensis (Steud.) Th. Dur. and Schinz. (giant rat’s tail grass) (Poaceae), invade rangelands and pastures in eastern Australia, costing the livestock industry approximately AUS$ 60 million per annum in grazing losses. Mechanical and chemical control options are costly and largely ineffective. Biological control is viewed as the most promising control option, however this management strategy has largely been avoided for grasses, due to their perceived lack of suitably host-specific and damaging natural enemies. In this thesis, the prospects for using biological control against S. pyramidalis and S. natalensis in Australia was assessed, in light of these potential challenges. Climate matching models were used to identify high-priority geographic regions within the plants’ native distributions to survey for potential biological control agents. High-priority regions to perform surveys were identified by modelling the climatic suitability for S. pyramidalis and S. natalensis in sub-Saharan Africa (i.e. their potential native ranges’), and climatic compatibility with regions where biological control is intended in Australia. High-priority regions for S. pyramidalis included: (1) coastal East Africa, ranging from north-eastern South Africa to Uganda, including south-eastern DRC, (2) some parts of West Africa, including inland regions of the Ivory Coast and western Nigeria, (3) northern Angola and (4) eastern Madagascar, and for S. natalensis included: (1) eastern South Africa, (2) eastern Zimbabwe, (3) Burundi, (4) central Ethiopia and (5) central Madagascar. Prospective control agents collected from these regions have the highest probability of establishing and proliferating in Australia, if released. In surveys of the insect assemblages on S. pyramidalis and S. natalensis in the climatically-matched region of eastern South Africa fifteen insect herbivores associated with the grasses were identified. Insect feeding guild, geographic distributions, and seasonal abundances suggest that three stem-boring phytophagous wasps, Tetramesa sp. 1, Tetramesa sp. 2 and Bruchophagus sp. 1 (Hymenoptera: Eurytomidae), have potential as control agents. Species accumulation curves indicated that additional surveys in South Africa are unlikely to yield additional potential control agents. Field host-range surveys of 47 non-target grass species in South Africa showed that Tetramesa sp. 1, Tetramesa sp. 2, and Bruchophagus sp. 1, were only recorded from S. pyramidalis and S. natalensis. Integrating field host-range with phylogenetic relationships between plant species indicated that no native Australian Sporobolus species or economic crops and pastures are expected to be attacked by these wasps. All three wasp species are predicted to be suitably host-specific for release in Australia. Three other endophagous herbivores attacked non-target native African Sporobolus species that share a close phylogenetic relationship to native Australian Sporobolus species, and therefore, demonstrate considerable risk of non-target damage. These species should not be considered as potential control agents. Under native-range, open-field conditions, Tetramesa sp. 1 caused an approximately 5-fold greater reduction in plant survival and reproductive output than Tetramesa sp. 2 and Bruchophagus sp. 1. Tetramesa sp. 1 in combination with Tetramesa sp. 2 did not significantly increase the level of damage, while Bruchophagus sp. 1 may decrease the efficiency of Tetramesa sp. 1, if released in combination. Tetramesa 1 is therefore the most promising candidate agent. Prioritising potential agents using predicted efficacy allowed otherwise equally suitable prospective agents to be prioritised in a strategic manner. Prioritising which natural enemies to target as biological control agents is a complex task. Field host range and damage assessments in the native range may provide more realistic data than typical studies performed under artificial conditions in a laboratory or quarantine. Moreover, it could assist practitioners in prioritising the most suitable agent(s) at the earliest stage in the programme as possible. This study demonstrated that grasses are suitable targets for biological control as they can harbour host-specific and damaging natural enemies.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2021
- Authors: Sutton, Guy Frederick
- Date: 2021
- Subjects: Grasses -- Diseases and pests , Bruchophagus , Wasps , Alien plants -- Biological control -- Australia , Sporobolus -- Biological control -- Africa , Sporobolus -- Biological control -- Australia , Insects as biological pest control agents -- Australia , Insects as biological pest control agents -- Africa
- Language: English
- Type: text , Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/172445 , vital:42201 , 10.21504/10962/172445
- Description: Sporobolus pyramidalis Beauv. and S. natalensis (Steud.) Th. Dur. and Schinz. (giant rat’s tail grass) (Poaceae), invade rangelands and pastures in eastern Australia, costing the livestock industry approximately AUS$ 60 million per annum in grazing losses. Mechanical and chemical control options are costly and largely ineffective. Biological control is viewed as the most promising control option, however this management strategy has largely been avoided for grasses, due to their perceived lack of suitably host-specific and damaging natural enemies. In this thesis, the prospects for using biological control against S. pyramidalis and S. natalensis in Australia was assessed, in light of these potential challenges. Climate matching models were used to identify high-priority geographic regions within the plants’ native distributions to survey for potential biological control agents. High-priority regions to perform surveys were identified by modelling the climatic suitability for S. pyramidalis and S. natalensis in sub-Saharan Africa (i.e. their potential native ranges’), and climatic compatibility with regions where biological control is intended in Australia. High-priority regions for S. pyramidalis included: (1) coastal East Africa, ranging from north-eastern South Africa to Uganda, including south-eastern DRC, (2) some parts of West Africa, including inland regions of the Ivory Coast and western Nigeria, (3) northern Angola and (4) eastern Madagascar, and for S. natalensis included: (1) eastern South Africa, (2) eastern Zimbabwe, (3) Burundi, (4) central Ethiopia and (5) central Madagascar. Prospective control agents collected from these regions have the highest probability of establishing and proliferating in Australia, if released. In surveys of the insect assemblages on S. pyramidalis and S. natalensis in the climatically-matched region of eastern South Africa fifteen insect herbivores associated with the grasses were identified. Insect feeding guild, geographic distributions, and seasonal abundances suggest that three stem-boring phytophagous wasps, Tetramesa sp. 1, Tetramesa sp. 2 and Bruchophagus sp. 1 (Hymenoptera: Eurytomidae), have potential as control agents. Species accumulation curves indicated that additional surveys in South Africa are unlikely to yield additional potential control agents. Field host-range surveys of 47 non-target grass species in South Africa showed that Tetramesa sp. 1, Tetramesa sp. 2, and Bruchophagus sp. 1, were only recorded from S. pyramidalis and S. natalensis. Integrating field host-range with phylogenetic relationships between plant species indicated that no native Australian Sporobolus species or economic crops and pastures are expected to be attacked by these wasps. All three wasp species are predicted to be suitably host-specific for release in Australia. Three other endophagous herbivores attacked non-target native African Sporobolus species that share a close phylogenetic relationship to native Australian Sporobolus species, and therefore, demonstrate considerable risk of non-target damage. These species should not be considered as potential control agents. Under native-range, open-field conditions, Tetramesa sp. 1 caused an approximately 5-fold greater reduction in plant survival and reproductive output than Tetramesa sp. 2 and Bruchophagus sp. 1. Tetramesa sp. 1 in combination with Tetramesa sp. 2 did not significantly increase the level of damage, while Bruchophagus sp. 1 may decrease the efficiency of Tetramesa sp. 1, if released in combination. Tetramesa 1 is therefore the most promising candidate agent. Prioritising potential agents using predicted efficacy allowed otherwise equally suitable prospective agents to be prioritised in a strategic manner. Prioritising which natural enemies to target as biological control agents is a complex task. Field host range and damage assessments in the native range may provide more realistic data than typical studies performed under artificial conditions in a laboratory or quarantine. Moreover, it could assist practitioners in prioritising the most suitable agent(s) at the earliest stage in the programme as possible. This study demonstrated that grasses are suitable targets for biological control as they can harbour host-specific and damaging natural enemies.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2021
Post-release evaluation of the biological control programme against Cereus jamacaru De Candolle (Cactaceae), in South Africa
- Authors: Sutton, Guy Frederick
- Date: 2017
- Language: English
- Type: text , Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/7982 , vital:21330
- Description: Cereus jamacaru De Candolle (Cactaceae) is an environment-transforming weed of both agricultural and wildlife habitats in South Africa. Weed infestations reduce carrying capacity of the land, and pose a risk to livestock, wildlife and human safety due to the plant’s spiny thorns. The weed is considered to be under complete biological control in South Africa, due to its introduced control agent, Hypogeococcus festerianus Lizer y Trelles (Hemiptera: Pseudococcidae), although observational reports suggest that the level of success achieved is variable. In this thesis, a formal post-release evaluation of this biological control programme was conducted, specifically to determine the efficacy of H. festerianus as a biological control agent, and to identify factors which may limit or constrain the level of success achieved by the control agent. These data were collected with the intention of improving the control of C. jamacaru in South Africa. A field-based study of C. jamacaru population demographics investigated the efficacy of H. festerianus as a biological control agent of the weed, by integrating weed growth, fecundity and survival metrics with C. jamacaru population dynamics and demographic patterns from 8 sites where H. festerianus was present and 14 sites where the control agent was absent. The findings indicated that H. festerianus significantly reduced weed fecundity, which resulted in fewer seedling recruits, and that levels of plant mortality were greater at sites where H. festerianus was present. The reduction in weed fecundity and survival translated into negative population-level consequences for H. festerianus. Weed-population age frequency distributions in the absence of H. festerianus demonstrated a “reverse J-shaped” distribution, indicative of high recruitment rates and population stability, while C. jamacaru populations infected with H. festerianus were described by bell-shaped distributions, and were typified by limited recruitment, or a complete lack thereof. By constraining recruitment and inhibiting selfregeneration, H. festerianus appears to regulate populations of C. jamacaru. Predation and parasitism of H. festerianus was believed to be a limiting factor for the biological control programme against C. jamacaru in South Africa, although no formal evaluation of this claim had been undertaken. Accordingly, the assemblage of natural enemies acquired by H. festerianus in South Africa was identified by field-collections of infected H. festerianus gall-material. Further, timed point-count surveys of natural enemies associated with H. festerianus were performed and integrated with the data on the impact of H. festerianus on weed population dynamics to assess the impact of two prominent predaceous taxa on H. festerianus efficacy as a biological control agent. Although H. festerianus had acquired a diverse suite of novel natural enemies in South Africa, this has not prevented the biocontrol agent from having an impact on C. jamacaru populations, although other subtler effects cannot be ruled out. This study showed that biological control efforts employing H. festerianus for the management of C. jamacaru have been successful. Furthermore, these data demonstrated the utility of retrospective analyses in developing and improving the science of biological control, specifically how to improve candidate agent prioritisation, determining how many agents are required for successful biological control, and how to evaluate the success of biological control efforts. Improvements in our theoretical understanding of biological control will undoubtedly reduce costs of biological control programmes, improve success rates, and increase the predictability of biological control.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2017
- Authors: Sutton, Guy Frederick
- Date: 2017
- Language: English
- Type: text , Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/7982 , vital:21330
- Description: Cereus jamacaru De Candolle (Cactaceae) is an environment-transforming weed of both agricultural and wildlife habitats in South Africa. Weed infestations reduce carrying capacity of the land, and pose a risk to livestock, wildlife and human safety due to the plant’s spiny thorns. The weed is considered to be under complete biological control in South Africa, due to its introduced control agent, Hypogeococcus festerianus Lizer y Trelles (Hemiptera: Pseudococcidae), although observational reports suggest that the level of success achieved is variable. In this thesis, a formal post-release evaluation of this biological control programme was conducted, specifically to determine the efficacy of H. festerianus as a biological control agent, and to identify factors which may limit or constrain the level of success achieved by the control agent. These data were collected with the intention of improving the control of C. jamacaru in South Africa. A field-based study of C. jamacaru population demographics investigated the efficacy of H. festerianus as a biological control agent of the weed, by integrating weed growth, fecundity and survival metrics with C. jamacaru population dynamics and demographic patterns from 8 sites where H. festerianus was present and 14 sites where the control agent was absent. The findings indicated that H. festerianus significantly reduced weed fecundity, which resulted in fewer seedling recruits, and that levels of plant mortality were greater at sites where H. festerianus was present. The reduction in weed fecundity and survival translated into negative population-level consequences for H. festerianus. Weed-population age frequency distributions in the absence of H. festerianus demonstrated a “reverse J-shaped” distribution, indicative of high recruitment rates and population stability, while C. jamacaru populations infected with H. festerianus were described by bell-shaped distributions, and were typified by limited recruitment, or a complete lack thereof. By constraining recruitment and inhibiting selfregeneration, H. festerianus appears to regulate populations of C. jamacaru. Predation and parasitism of H. festerianus was believed to be a limiting factor for the biological control programme against C. jamacaru in South Africa, although no formal evaluation of this claim had been undertaken. Accordingly, the assemblage of natural enemies acquired by H. festerianus in South Africa was identified by field-collections of infected H. festerianus gall-material. Further, timed point-count surveys of natural enemies associated with H. festerianus were performed and integrated with the data on the impact of H. festerianus on weed population dynamics to assess the impact of two prominent predaceous taxa on H. festerianus efficacy as a biological control agent. Although H. festerianus had acquired a diverse suite of novel natural enemies in South Africa, this has not prevented the biocontrol agent from having an impact on C. jamacaru populations, although other subtler effects cannot be ruled out. This study showed that biological control efforts employing H. festerianus for the management of C. jamacaru have been successful. Furthermore, these data demonstrated the utility of retrospective analyses in developing and improving the science of biological control, specifically how to improve candidate agent prioritisation, determining how many agents are required for successful biological control, and how to evaluate the success of biological control efforts. Improvements in our theoretical understanding of biological control will undoubtedly reduce costs of biological control programmes, improve success rates, and increase the predictability of biological control.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2017
- «
- ‹
- 1
- ›
- »