On locating the experiences of second year science students from rural areas in Higher Education in the field of science: lived rural experiences
- Authors: Madondo, Nkosinathi Emmanuel
- Date: 2020
- Subjects: Science students -- South Africa , Rural college students -- South Africa , Science -- Study and teaching (Higher) -- South Africa , Curriculum change -- South Africa , Learning -- Evaluation , Social justice and education -- South Africa , Action research in education -- South Africa , Participant observation -- South Africa , Critical realism , Ethnoscience -- South Africa , Focus groups -- South Africa , Bernstein, Basil
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/145758 , vital:38464
- Description: This study was designed to investigate the experiences of Second Year Science students who come from rural backgrounds within a Higher Education context. The purpose of the study was to understand the enabling and/or constraining factors that influence the teaching and learning of Second Year Science students who come from rural contexts. Given this purpose, the participants that were considered relevant to answer the question: What are the enabling and constraining factors that influence teaching and learning of second year Science students who come from rural backgrounds at a South African University? were students from rural areas enrolled in the Faculty of Science at the research site, academic teachers and senior leaders’, and roles in providing enabling and/or constraining teaching and learning environment. The phenomenon under investigation was thus, the extent to which the teaching and learning environment, in the field of science, enable or constrain access to the Discourse of science for students who come from rural areas. To generate data, the study used focus group discussions, Participatory Learning and Action (PLA) tools as part of Participatory Action Research (PAR), digital documentaries, as well as academic teachers’ rich descriptions of the rationale for the design and delivery techniques of their modules by means of focus group interviews, as well as curriculum review documents. The purpose of Action Research (AR) in this study was to enable change by way of advancing a self-consciousness, envisaged to yield some action based on the enablements or constraints identified by the participants involved. Archer’s (1995, 1996) analytical dualism was used as the analytical framework to identify the interplay of structural, cultural and agential mechanisms shaping the emergence of, and practices associated with students’ experiences of the science curriculum and academic teachers’ observations of these experiences. Bernstein’s pedagogic device was also used to explain the options that academic teachers have to shape the curriculum, a curriculum that would reflect the experiences of the heterogeneity of the student cohort when designing their course guides, for example. The analysis thus used Archer’s (1995, 1996) Morphogenesis/Morphostasis framework through which change or non-change can be observed over time. The work of Bhaskar (1975, 1979) was important in this regard because it allows us to separate what we see, experience and understand (in the transitive world) from what is independent of our thoughts and experiences (the intransitive world) when conducting scientific enquiry, so that we are able to deduce the ‘real’ factors that enable and constrain the events and experiences being studied. Since there are multiple mechanisms operative that can act to include or exclude students in Science classrooms, particularly those who come from lower class, including those who come from rural areas, this study focuses on curriculum as one mechanism that can be at play in the problem of exclusion. In this study, I argue, the University and its structures like curriculum are not neutral but are historical, cultural, political and social, which is why persistent apartheid legacy and coloniality were seen as playing a role in how the curriculum is designed and thus enacted. This is the reason, a decolonial gaze was adopted in order to engage with social justice issues and in the process tease out the social relations of knowledge practices. A decolonial gaze provided a way to re-describe the structuring of the curriculum and the contradictions it sets up for black students, particularly those who come from lower class backgrounds, including those from rural areas. Findings reveal that the way in which the science curriculum (and/or teaching and learning) is structured, and thus enacted, tends to favour certain worldviews to the exclusion of others. Also, findings show that when students are presented with knowledge that seems completely separate from them, their identities, their heritage, their backgrounds and value systems, accessing that knowledge can seem inordinately difficult. Consequently, students from rural contexts are often alienated, because the “world” they bring and know is often not considered part of the starting point, neither is it seen as relevant when teaching the science curriculum. There is therefore a clear need to bring something ‘from home’ into our teaching as a means of reassuring students that all is not foreign and that what they already know is valuable.
- Full Text:
An investigation into the promotion of productive learning dispositions in government policies and teacher assessment in Grade R and Grade 1
- Authors: Long, Roxanne
- Date: 2015
- Subjects: Learning, Psychology of , Early childhood education -- Evaluation , Learning -- Evaluation , Educational psychology
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MEd
- Identifier: vital:2018 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1017182
- Description: The impetus for this study came from the increasing acknowledgement of learning dispositions as a central, yet largely under explored area of numeracy learning, in both international education literature and in the current work conducted by the South African Numeracy Chair, based at Rhodes University. This coupled with my own personal interest in the crucial transitional phase between Grade R (the year before formal schooling) and Grade 1 and the role of developing progressively strengthened learning dispositions, particularly in relation to numeracy learning, to enable this transition. This, together with the lack of research around what constitutes a quality Grade R programme, especially in South Africa, inspired an investigation into the promotion of key productive learning dispositions within current government policy and in teacher assessment practices across Grade R and Grade 1 in six local schools. I designed a qualitative research study underpinned by a socio-cultural theoretical perspective that foregrounds learning. Within this broad theoretical perspective I drew on two key analytic frameworks that cohere with this socio cultural view that prioritises learning dispositions (ways of being, habits of mind). In particular the work of Kilpatrick et al. (2001) and Carr & Claxton (2010), in defining essential elements of key productive learning dispositions, were combined to enable the development of an indicator matrix used for the analysis of current government policy and teacher assessment practices in the Grade R and Grade 1. Additionally empirical data from the study enabled extension and adaptation of the indicator matrix derived from key literature. The research contributes an analysis of various curriculum and policy documents across Grade R and 1 in terms of the inclusion and promotion of learning dispositions. The presences of certain promoted dispositions are compared with international literature and frameworks and certain absences or under represented dispositions are noted. The empirical data derived from Gr R and Gr 1 teacher questionnaires and exemplar reports across 6 schools are analysed and related back to policy. Similarities and differences across teachers in different grades and teachers in different schools are discussed. The findings point towards several avenues of research and also provide an emergent dispositional discourse from empirical data, policy analysis and literature that could enable engagement between various stakeholders around the notion of learning dispositions as a central feature of schooling in the Grade R to Grade 1 transition. It is argued from the data that the inclusion of exemplar reports, in teacher assessment policy guides, which indicate possible ways to communicate dispositional priorities to both parents and learners, would assist teachers in achieving greater coherence between dispositions promoted in the classroom and those assessed and reported on.
- Full Text:
Perceptions of being a learner: an investigation into how first year Journalism students at a South African university construct themselves as learners
- Authors: Lunga, Carolyne Mande
- Date: 2015
- Subjects: Journalism -- Study and teaching (Higher) -- South Africa , Students -- Attitudes , Students -- Self-rating of -- South Africa , Discourse analysis, Narrative , Active learning -- South Africa , Learning -- Evaluation , Learning, Psychology of , College freshmen -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MEd
- Identifier: vital:1332 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1020026
- Description: The aim of the research reported in this document was to explore the ways in which first year Journalism students at a South African University construct themselves as learners. The research adopted a case study approach of purposively selected first year journalism students. In exploring this area, focus group and individual in-depth interviewing were employed which illuminated important aspects of learner identity construction. In order to make sense of these self-constructions, the research was located in the larger debates on discourse as espoused by Michel Foucault who argues that discourse constructs subjectivities. The research demonstrated that there were various discourses at play which influenced how these learners spoke and behaved. The influence of these discourses on learners' experiences varied at different times of the year. For example, the awarding of the Duly Performed (DP) certificate for students who met the minimum attendance and work requirements of a particular course, the giving of tests, exercises and examinations were some of the technologies that 'forced' students into compliance. In terms of identity formation, the heterogeneous nature of 'being' a journalism 'student' revealed that the different discourses at play influenced learner behaviour and that their identities continued to change over the year. Doing additional subjects such as Sociology, Drama, Art History and others at the same time as Journalism and Media Studies also meant that the learners had to negotiate the differing role requirements.
- Full Text: