An evaluation of recirculating artificial stream designs for acute toxicity testing using two South African Ephemeroptera species exposed to sodium sulphate
- Authors: Binder, Markus
- Date: 2000
- Subjects: Water -- Pollution -- Toxicology , Toxicology -- Research , Aquatic organisms -- Effect of water pollution on , Sodium sulfate , Mayflies
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5690 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1005376 , Water -- Pollution -- Toxicology , Toxicology -- Research , Aquatic organisms -- Effect of water pollution on , Sodium sulfate , Mayflies
- Description: Three artificial stream designs, termed Large Artificial Stream Units (LASUs), Raceways, and Channels, at two major scales (1700 L, 12.5 L and 20 L recirculated volume) were developed at the Institute for Water Research, Rhodes University, Grahamstown, in order to explore the possibilities of using indigenous rheophilic macroinvertebrates in routine toxicity tests. This study compared these systems, using 96h-EC50 values from sodium sulphate toxicity tests as the experimental response. Two local Ephemeroptera (Leptophlebiidae: Adenophlebia auriculata Eaton, and Baetidae: Afroptilum sudafricanum Lestage) were evaluated for their suitability in routine toxicity tests; and the possible effects of elevated salinity levels in South African rivers on the test species were assessed. Two sets of experiments with each mayfly species were conducted, following an unreplicated regression design. Dechlorinated tap water was used as the water source. Experiments in the Channels were repeated to determine experimental variability. Results were compared statistically by testing for overlap of 95% confidence limits (95%Cls) of EC50 values. The differences between A. auriculata EC50 values in the different systems were statistically significant (no overlap of 95%CLs), but they were not more variable than has been considered normal for biological systems (Coefficient of variation 20.1 %; ratio of greatest EC50 / smallest EC50 1.63). The differences were not related to the scale or the average current velocity characteristic of each stream design (average current velocity LASUs - Raceways - Channels 0.090 - 0.083 - 0.038 m/s). The Channels proved to be most efficient with regard to practical performance as they are portable and easily transportable, user-friendly, reliable, splash-free, cost effective to construct, and can easily be adapted to specific requirements. These systems are therefore recommended for regular use. The suitability of the two mayfly species for routine toxicity testing was evaluated. A. auriculata EC50 values showed a significant negative correlation with the corresponding average body-size (range 1476 - 1610 μm, mean 1555 μm). The different average body-sizes probably reflected the abundance of a certain size range present in the Palmiet River at the time of collection. Both species reacted similarly to Na₂S0₄ (similar slopes of the toxicity curves), identifying this salt as a slow acting toxicant. A. sudafricanum populations were more sensitive to Na₂S0₄ (EC50 3.404 g/L) than A. auriculata (EC50 8.090 g/L), probably because of its smaller body-size (mean 709 μm) and a lack of extremely tolerant individuals. In comparison to other freshwater macro invertebrates, including the standard toxicity test organism Daphnia spp., both mayfly species seemed to be moderately tolerant of Na₂S0₄; therefore there was no particular advantage to using these indigenous taxa rather than Daphnia spp. An assessment of the effects of elevated salinity/TDS levels on the test taxa yielded preliminary insights. A NaCI-EC50 for A. sudafricanum could be extrapolated and suggested a higher sensitivity to Na₂S0₄ than to NaCl. When Na₂S0₄ EC50 values of both species were compared to selected TDS levels of South African rivers, 4. auriculata would mostly not be affected, but A. sudafricanum might occasionally suffer from sub-lethal effects, depending on the sulphate proportion of the TDS. The South African guideline for TDS seemed to protect both species sufficiently.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2000
The use of indigenous macroinvertebrates and Daphnia pulex in acute toxicity testing
- Authors: Everitt, Victoria Jane
- Date: 2000
- Subjects: Water -- Pollution -- Toxicology , Toxicity testing , Daphnia pulex
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5795 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1005483
- Description: Aquatic toxicology has been identified as a valuable tool in the identification and management of chemical pollution in aquatic ecosystems. Standardised methodologies for acute aquatic bioassays have been adopted from international agencies. As a result of these standard methods, the use of laboratory cultured organisms for toxicity testing has been more popular than that of indigenous field-caught organisms. Included in these adopted methods are those for the cultured crustacean Daphnia pUlex. D.pulex is adapted to living in standing water and the suitability of this species to determine toxic effects for South African riverine environments, which are largely flowing, has been questioned. Thus this thesis is a case-study ofthe use of D.pulex and indigenous site-specific macroinvertebrates as toxicity test organisms for setting acute water quality guidelines to protect aquatic ecosystems. The study highlights site-specific problems such as reference sites and organism identification. The acute tolerance of selected indigenous invertebrates was compared to that of D. pulex, using both a single-substance reference toxicant (zinc) and selected whole efiluents. The significance of source population and culture age as a potential source of biological variability between D.pulex cultures was also investigated. D.pulex cultures have been initiated in South Africa from females collected from a number of different local populations; also it is assumed that no genetic change (due to mutation) occurs within a D.pulex culture over time. In order to establish if source population and culture age are a source of biological variability between D.pulex experiments, the acute tolerJuce to zinc of two different D.pulex populations and three different generations within a population were compared. Due to experimental variability results were inconclusive, and differences in tolerance as a result of population difference or culture age could not be determined with confidence. The acute tolerance of D.pulex to a single reference chemical (zinc) and selected whole efiluents was compared to that of selected indigenous invertebrates. Acute 48 h D.pulex zinc tolerance (LC50 range: 0.22 - 0.60 mg/l Zn) was found to be more sensitive than acute 96 h tolerances shown by mayfly species A.fconurus peringueyi (Heptageniidae) (LC50: 17.42 mg/l Zn), Euthrauluselegans (Leptophlebiidae) (LC50: 0.98 mg/IZn), Ba~tidae (LC50: 0.94mg/IZn) and shrimp, Caradina nilotica (Atyidae) (LC50: 3.17 mg/l Zn). This result suggests that guidelines for zinc set using D.pulex will protect the selected indigenous invertebrates. Selected whole eftluents were not acutely toxic to either D.pulex or selected indigenous invertebrates. These experiments were used as a case study for method development regarding the comparative use of D.pulex and indigenous invertebrates in acute whole eftluent toxicity testing. Finally, it is recommended that a suite of indigenous organisms (e.g. macroinvertebrates, fish and algae), as well as laboratory cultured D.pulex, be used in the initial setting of guidelines and that D.pulex be used for routine compliance monitoring. It is futher recommended that a suite of available monitoring methods, such as chemical and biomonitoring methodologies, be used in conjuction with toxicity testing in water quality management.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2000