Towards the development of species-specific fish production models for small reservoirs in Southern Africa
- Authors: Potts, Warren M
- Date: 2004
- Subjects: Freshwater fishes -- Africa, Southern Fish populations -- Africa, Southern Fisheries -- Africa, Southern Sustainable fisheries -- Africa, Southern Labeo -- Reproduction Cyprinidae -- Africa, Southern
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:5330 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1005176
- Description: The fish populations in small southern African reservoirs are largely unexploited and there is potential for fisheries development. However, the development of sustainable fisheries requires reliable estimates of potential yield or production. Empirical models that have been developed to predict fish production only apply to large water bodies and only predict total fish production, not the production of individual species. Small reservoirs generally have few commercially important species and therefore species-specific fish production models are an alternative approach. The small reservoirs of the Eastern Cape are dominated by the moggel (Labeo umbratus). The principal objectives of this thesis were to gain an understanding of the ecology of small reservoirs and the function of moggel in these systems. This information was used to design a research approach to rapidly develop species-specific models for small reservoirs in southern Africa. The limnology of two small reservoirs was compared. During the study period the reservoirs were turbid and showed a warm, monomictic pattern of thermal stratification. Anthropogenic pressure in the reservoir catchments appeared to be the overriding factor increasing the nutrient input to the reservoirs and consequently, influencing the biomass of algae in the reservoirs. The feeding biology of moggel in Katriver and Laing reservoirs was examined. Moggel are detrivorous and successfully digested diatoms. The slower growth rate of moggel in Katriver reservoir was attributed to the poorer nutritional value of the diet as a consequence of the lower concentration of diatoms in the detrital aggregate. The reproductive characteristics of moggel were examined in four reservoirs. Moggel were able to reproduce successfully in the reservoirs. This could be attributed to their r-selected reproductive strategy, with a high fecundity and an extended spawning season and their ability to spawn in a floodplain environment. Differences in recruitment success between years were found to be a consequence of the timing and duration of seasonal rains. The number of mature females in a population and the availability of suitable spawning habitat influenced recruitment success. The life history of the moggel in five reservoirs was compared. Growth appeared to be related to food availability, while mortality was lower in the populations where food was abundant and there were less predatory species. Size and age at maturity were not affected by environmental factors, but were dependent on growth and mortality. Three contrasting methods were used to estimate moggel gillnet selectivity. The Sechin, direct fyke net method and length-structured model all yielded similar results and correction factors obtained from the selectivity study were applied to the gillnet data to estimate the fish population size and structure in each reservoir. Using information from the life history and selectivity studies, the biomass and production of five moggel populations was estimated and related to abiotic and biotic factors in the reservoirs and their catchments. Moggel biomass and production was dependent on the biomass of algae, which was dependent on morphoedaphic characteristics of the reservoirs. Small, shallow reservoirs with a reasonable amount of human habitation in their catchments would sustain the highest algal biomass and provided they had adequate spawning habitat would also have the highest moggel biomass and production. The future research requirements for small reservoir fisheries are outlined and include a three-year program to develop a species-specific production model for any of the dominant species.
- Full Text:
- Authors: Potts, Warren M
- Date: 2004
- Subjects: Freshwater fishes -- Africa, Southern Fish populations -- Africa, Southern Fisheries -- Africa, Southern Sustainable fisheries -- Africa, Southern Labeo -- Reproduction Cyprinidae -- Africa, Southern
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:5330 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1005176
- Description: The fish populations in small southern African reservoirs are largely unexploited and there is potential for fisheries development. However, the development of sustainable fisheries requires reliable estimates of potential yield or production. Empirical models that have been developed to predict fish production only apply to large water bodies and only predict total fish production, not the production of individual species. Small reservoirs generally have few commercially important species and therefore species-specific fish production models are an alternative approach. The small reservoirs of the Eastern Cape are dominated by the moggel (Labeo umbratus). The principal objectives of this thesis were to gain an understanding of the ecology of small reservoirs and the function of moggel in these systems. This information was used to design a research approach to rapidly develop species-specific models for small reservoirs in southern Africa. The limnology of two small reservoirs was compared. During the study period the reservoirs were turbid and showed a warm, monomictic pattern of thermal stratification. Anthropogenic pressure in the reservoir catchments appeared to be the overriding factor increasing the nutrient input to the reservoirs and consequently, influencing the biomass of algae in the reservoirs. The feeding biology of moggel in Katriver and Laing reservoirs was examined. Moggel are detrivorous and successfully digested diatoms. The slower growth rate of moggel in Katriver reservoir was attributed to the poorer nutritional value of the diet as a consequence of the lower concentration of diatoms in the detrital aggregate. The reproductive characteristics of moggel were examined in four reservoirs. Moggel were able to reproduce successfully in the reservoirs. This could be attributed to their r-selected reproductive strategy, with a high fecundity and an extended spawning season and their ability to spawn in a floodplain environment. Differences in recruitment success between years were found to be a consequence of the timing and duration of seasonal rains. The number of mature females in a population and the availability of suitable spawning habitat influenced recruitment success. The life history of the moggel in five reservoirs was compared. Growth appeared to be related to food availability, while mortality was lower in the populations where food was abundant and there were less predatory species. Size and age at maturity were not affected by environmental factors, but were dependent on growth and mortality. Three contrasting methods were used to estimate moggel gillnet selectivity. The Sechin, direct fyke net method and length-structured model all yielded similar results and correction factors obtained from the selectivity study were applied to the gillnet data to estimate the fish population size and structure in each reservoir. Using information from the life history and selectivity studies, the biomass and production of five moggel populations was estimated and related to abiotic and biotic factors in the reservoirs and their catchments. Moggel biomass and production was dependent on the biomass of algae, which was dependent on morphoedaphic characteristics of the reservoirs. Small, shallow reservoirs with a reasonable amount of human habitation in their catchments would sustain the highest algal biomass and provided they had adequate spawning habitat would also have the highest moggel biomass and production. The future research requirements for small reservoir fisheries are outlined and include a three-year program to develop a species-specific production model for any of the dominant species.
- Full Text:
A nutritional evaluation of effluent grown algae and zooplakton as feed ingredients for Xiphohorous helleri, Poecilia reticulata and Poecilia velifera (Pisces : Poeciliidae)
- Authors: Potts, Warren M
- Date: 1998
- Subjects: Poeciliidae , Poeciliidae -- Nutrition , Zooplankton , Algae , Poeciliidae -- Feeding and feeds
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5306 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1005151 , Poeciliidae , Poeciliidae -- Nutrition , Zooplankton , Algae , Poeciliidae -- Feeding and feeds
- Description: The aim of this study was to evaluate the nutritional value of algae and zooplankton grown in an algal integrated ponding system for poeciliids. The available information on the nutritional requirements of poeciliids was compared with a proximate analysis of the algae and zooplankton. The effluent grown algae and zooplankton had a crude protein value of 41.47 ± 0.2% and 36.84 ± 0.3%, a lipid content of 4.8 ±. 0.4% and 11.1 ± 0.8% and a carbohydrate content of 35.13 ± 0.8% and 31.06 ± 0.6% respectively. These values compared favourably with those of the known nutritional requirements of poeciliids. To test if the nutritional value of the algae and zooplankton in the AlPS was constant, the species composition of the algae and the crude protein content of the algae and zooplankton in the high rate oxidation ponds were measured monthly and bi-weekly for a year respectively. The species composition remained fairly stable for the duration of the experiment and the average protein composition of the algae and zooplankton was 43.4 ± 4.4% and 38.6 ±2.8% respectively. This indicated that the algae and zooplankton in the AlPS provided high protein biomass through the year. The quality of the effluent grown algal and zooplankton biomass was evaluated by analysing their amino acid composition and comparing it with the amino acid composition of the body tissue of X. helleri. With respect to the amino acid composition of the body tissue of X. helleri, the amino acid profile of the algae had a 69% and the zooplankton a 63% similarity. The quality of the pure algal and zooplankton protein was also tested biologically, by feeding them directly to poeciliids during a ten week growth trial. The algae and zooplankton diets did not result in adequate growth compared to poeciliids which were fed a formulated control diet. The initial growth trial also evaluated the effect of processing on the chemical composition of the algae and its biological effect on fish fed with it. There were no significant differences in the chemical composition of fresh and sun dried algae and this was reflected in the growth rates of the fish which did not differ significantly. Freeze dried algae had a lower crude protein content than fresh and sun dried algae and a poorer amino acid composition. Fish fed freeze dried algae exhibited poorer growth and survival in comparison to the other treatments. The gut transit times of X. helleri and the gastric evacuation times of poeciliids were determined using colour dyes incorporated in the diet and by sacrificing fish at predetermined intervals after feeding respectively. The gut transit time of X. helleri fed a sun dried algal diet and a formulated diet was 225 ± 8.55 minutes and 261.93 ± 10.86 minutes respectively. The gastric evacuation times of X. helleri, P. reticu/ata and P. velifera were 7, 9 and 8 hours respectively. Since the maximum amount of food in the hindgut after feeding was detemined to be 3, 5 and 3 hours in X. helleri, P. reticulata and P. velifera respectively, fish were sacrificed at these times in the digestibility study. The digestibility of sun dried algae was determined using 1 % chromic oxide as an internal marker in the algae. The apparent crude protein digestibility of sun dried effluent grown algae ranged from 65%-75% in the three poeciliid species. Based on the results of the chemical and biological analysis of the algae and zooplankton, conventional diets incorporating algae at 5% and 20% protein inclusion levels were formulated. These diets and a treatment in which zooplankton, reared in the AlPS were fed as a dietary supplement to a formulated diet were fed to poeciliids for twelve weeks. No significant differences in the growth of poeciliids fed any of the test diets were observed. It was concluded that the algae could be incorporated into poeciliid formulated diets up to level of 20% protein inclusion without any negative effect on the growth of the fish. The chemical and biological evaluation of the algae suggested that it had a similar nutritional quality to soyabean meal. Poeciliid growth was not enhanced with a zooplankton supplement, however a possible low feeding rate by poeciliids on the zooplankton as a result of their small size may have affected the result. The colour enhancement potential of effluent grown algae and zooplankton was evaluated biologically in ten and twelve week growth trials using visual observation (31 people) and by using a chromameter. While pure, sun dried algae significantly enhanced the colour of P. reticulata, no significant differences in the colour of poeciliids were observed or recorded when fish were fed diets incorporating sun dried algae up to levels of 20% protein inclusion. The effect of effluent grown algae and zooplankton on poeciliid health was also tested biologically in the ten and twelve week growth trials. The high mortalities (75%-84%) recorded for X. hel/eri when fed the pure algal and zooplankton diets were considered to be as a result of the nutritional inadequacy of the diets since there were significantly less mortalities in fish fed the formulated control diet and 63% of the fish that died during the course of the trial were emaciated. In addition, fewer mortalities (10%-40%) were recorded in X. hel/eri fed the nutritionally adequate formulated diets in the twelve week growth trial. No symptoms of disease were recorded in the twelve week growth trial and the algae was considered to have no toxicological or pathological effects on poeciliids. Centrifugation, sand filtration, sedimentation, microstraining and biological harvest were evaluated as methods of small scale algal harvest from the high rate oxidation ponds. Algae could be harvested most efficiently with little associated labour by sedimentation (without flocculating agents) and by microstraining with 60IJm mesh. Effluent grown algae can replace conventional feed ingredients up to a level of 20% protein inclusion without negatively effecting the growth, colour, health or survival of poeciliids.
- Full Text:
- Authors: Potts, Warren M
- Date: 1998
- Subjects: Poeciliidae , Poeciliidae -- Nutrition , Zooplankton , Algae , Poeciliidae -- Feeding and feeds
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5306 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1005151 , Poeciliidae , Poeciliidae -- Nutrition , Zooplankton , Algae , Poeciliidae -- Feeding and feeds
- Description: The aim of this study was to evaluate the nutritional value of algae and zooplankton grown in an algal integrated ponding system for poeciliids. The available information on the nutritional requirements of poeciliids was compared with a proximate analysis of the algae and zooplankton. The effluent grown algae and zooplankton had a crude protein value of 41.47 ± 0.2% and 36.84 ± 0.3%, a lipid content of 4.8 ±. 0.4% and 11.1 ± 0.8% and a carbohydrate content of 35.13 ± 0.8% and 31.06 ± 0.6% respectively. These values compared favourably with those of the known nutritional requirements of poeciliids. To test if the nutritional value of the algae and zooplankton in the AlPS was constant, the species composition of the algae and the crude protein content of the algae and zooplankton in the high rate oxidation ponds were measured monthly and bi-weekly for a year respectively. The species composition remained fairly stable for the duration of the experiment and the average protein composition of the algae and zooplankton was 43.4 ± 4.4% and 38.6 ±2.8% respectively. This indicated that the algae and zooplankton in the AlPS provided high protein biomass through the year. The quality of the effluent grown algal and zooplankton biomass was evaluated by analysing their amino acid composition and comparing it with the amino acid composition of the body tissue of X. helleri. With respect to the amino acid composition of the body tissue of X. helleri, the amino acid profile of the algae had a 69% and the zooplankton a 63% similarity. The quality of the pure algal and zooplankton protein was also tested biologically, by feeding them directly to poeciliids during a ten week growth trial. The algae and zooplankton diets did not result in adequate growth compared to poeciliids which were fed a formulated control diet. The initial growth trial also evaluated the effect of processing on the chemical composition of the algae and its biological effect on fish fed with it. There were no significant differences in the chemical composition of fresh and sun dried algae and this was reflected in the growth rates of the fish which did not differ significantly. Freeze dried algae had a lower crude protein content than fresh and sun dried algae and a poorer amino acid composition. Fish fed freeze dried algae exhibited poorer growth and survival in comparison to the other treatments. The gut transit times of X. helleri and the gastric evacuation times of poeciliids were determined using colour dyes incorporated in the diet and by sacrificing fish at predetermined intervals after feeding respectively. The gut transit time of X. helleri fed a sun dried algal diet and a formulated diet was 225 ± 8.55 minutes and 261.93 ± 10.86 minutes respectively. The gastric evacuation times of X. helleri, P. reticu/ata and P. velifera were 7, 9 and 8 hours respectively. Since the maximum amount of food in the hindgut after feeding was detemined to be 3, 5 and 3 hours in X. helleri, P. reticulata and P. velifera respectively, fish were sacrificed at these times in the digestibility study. The digestibility of sun dried algae was determined using 1 % chromic oxide as an internal marker in the algae. The apparent crude protein digestibility of sun dried effluent grown algae ranged from 65%-75% in the three poeciliid species. Based on the results of the chemical and biological analysis of the algae and zooplankton, conventional diets incorporating algae at 5% and 20% protein inclusion levels were formulated. These diets and a treatment in which zooplankton, reared in the AlPS were fed as a dietary supplement to a formulated diet were fed to poeciliids for twelve weeks. No significant differences in the growth of poeciliids fed any of the test diets were observed. It was concluded that the algae could be incorporated into poeciliid formulated diets up to level of 20% protein inclusion without any negative effect on the growth of the fish. The chemical and biological evaluation of the algae suggested that it had a similar nutritional quality to soyabean meal. Poeciliid growth was not enhanced with a zooplankton supplement, however a possible low feeding rate by poeciliids on the zooplankton as a result of their small size may have affected the result. The colour enhancement potential of effluent grown algae and zooplankton was evaluated biologically in ten and twelve week growth trials using visual observation (31 people) and by using a chromameter. While pure, sun dried algae significantly enhanced the colour of P. reticulata, no significant differences in the colour of poeciliids were observed or recorded when fish were fed diets incorporating sun dried algae up to levels of 20% protein inclusion. The effect of effluent grown algae and zooplankton on poeciliid health was also tested biologically in the ten and twelve week growth trials. The high mortalities (75%-84%) recorded for X. hel/eri when fed the pure algal and zooplankton diets were considered to be as a result of the nutritional inadequacy of the diets since there were significantly less mortalities in fish fed the formulated control diet and 63% of the fish that died during the course of the trial were emaciated. In addition, fewer mortalities (10%-40%) were recorded in X. hel/eri fed the nutritionally adequate formulated diets in the twelve week growth trial. No symptoms of disease were recorded in the twelve week growth trial and the algae was considered to have no toxicological or pathological effects on poeciliids. Centrifugation, sand filtration, sedimentation, microstraining and biological harvest were evaluated as methods of small scale algal harvest from the high rate oxidation ponds. Algae could be harvested most efficiently with little associated labour by sedimentation (without flocculating agents) and by microstraining with 60IJm mesh. Effluent grown algae can replace conventional feed ingredients up to a level of 20% protein inclusion without negatively effecting the growth, colour, health or survival of poeciliids.
- Full Text:
- «
- ‹
- 1
- ›
- »